Recycling the same hymns from the previous year’s Mass
  • How many of you recycle the same hymns each year? I noticed that last Sunday the hymns didn’t match the Mass, they sounded like they were recycled from a funeral Mass, as they didn’t fit the Mass. Then this past weekend when our MD was absent, as I suspected he would be given the date, they were the same readings from the same Sunday from last year, but they didn’t match. They were also pretty rough given that the people filling in struggled with them, mostly his pianist. It made for an excellent opportunity to practice mortification of trying to not make faces during every derailment. 2/2 time ≠ 2/4 time. The accent is different.
  • In my spreadsheet I have some hymns and motets highlighted blue because I've decided they are perfect for that feast and position in mass. E.g. "Bone Pastor" on Easter II at communion, or Come Holy Ghost (LAMBILOTTE) as entrance on Pentecost. Maybe 20% of the schedule is in blue. Those are repeated each year, but it's according to the feast, not the calendar date.
  • I definitely use previous years as a reference. That said, however, the three-year lectionary does make it a bit trickier at times.
  • ServiamScores
    Posts: 3,450
    It depends. I have a 3 year cycle where the hymns are based on the propers and the readings. If the offertory hymn, for instance, is based on the offertory antiphon (which applies regardless) then I will use it again. If it's based on the gospel reading which is different, I will change to a different hymn that makes more sense. So ultimately it depends on how that week was set up the year before.

    For feasts / solemnities that are fixed year to year, I generally use 75% of the same year over year just so there is some consistency, and really there is no need to change it anyway.
  • Solemnities make sense. I’m looking forward to To Jesus Christ our Sovereign King, even though I already know the congregation and choir are going to let me down with either lack of singing or lack of energy singing and weak organ because the choir doesn’t know hymns well enough due to a lack of processions. It’s so disappointing. Hopefully we won’t have a repeat of The King of Glory. Too many haunting images of Stephen Colbert’s liturgical dance video.
    Thanked by 1Roborgelmeister
  • ServiamScores
    Posts: 3,450
    I have never met a congregation that didn’t sing Ich Glaub an Gott robustly.
  • MatthewRoth
    Posts: 3,886
    I could rotate between the Mass and Vespers and no one would notice over two years. I will do more than that, and it’s exciting having a full repertoire. We just did SALZBURG, with Hail Redeemer King Divine as found in HPSC. It’s a brilliant pairing.
  • I have never met a congregation that didn’t sing Ich Glaub an Gott robustly.


    You should meet mine. Not even the choir sings it robustly. It’s such a let down from when our Latin Mass community would sing it as loudly as possible processing back into the church during our Corpus Christi procession. Our organist would run back to the church ahead of the procession so that as we processed into the church singing, the organ would be so loud.

    Our Latin Mass community doesn’t sing during Mass, and the current choir sings everything painfully slow with an inconsistent tempo, and of course it’s always an unfamiliar hymn with 7 verses, and they sing all 7 verses.

    Meanwhile, the English congregation turns around to watch the choir sing and then gives them a round of applause at the end. I said, “screw it!” on All Saints Day and sang robustly, even if the choir wasn’t going to be robust with their singing. I waited 7 years to sing For All the Saints.
  • I have never met a congregation that didn’t sing Ich Glaub an Gott robustly.


    Mine wouldn't even know the tune.

    As for recycling, it depends on what musicians / singers are available that day (we don't follow a predictable pattern, it varies based on other commitments). If we have the same musician as last year or 3-years-ago, yes it's likely we'll recycle, and no one will mind. Especially on days when we get many sporadic attendees, ie the "C&E Catholics" - they crave the familiar.
  • Just out of curiosity, in the EF, The Solemnity of Christ the King is an actual solemnity, so I always assumed it was also a solemnity in the OF, albeit a different date to emphasize the eschatological nature of Christ’s return in glory with the heavenly host of angels and trumpets, etc as a stark contrast to his quiet humble first coming at Christmas. However, in my experience, it never feels like a solemnity. It’s always just like any other Sunday. Am I wrong in assuming it’s supposed to be celebrated as a liturgical Solemnity?
  • chonakchonak
    Posts: 9,353
    I think keeping many hymns from year to year is a beautiful practice, especially on major feast days. It acts as a reminder that the liturgy is something given to us, that we don't have to reinvent, that we can simply carry out without any surprises.
  • AbbysmumAbbysmum
    Posts: 229
    I think keeping many hymns from year to year is a beautiful practice, especially on major feast days. It acts as a reminder that the liturgy is something given to us, that we don't have to reinvent, that we can simply carry out without any surprises.


    This. We've been doing this for awhile now. Especially if it has music particular to that day - people grow to know it and love it and look forward to it. It enables their ability to participate. It emphasizes the seasonal nature of our liturgical year.

    That being said, I will change up maybe 1 piece, especially if there's a choral piece that the congregation won't necessarily be singing.
    Thanked by 1CHGiffen
  • MatthewRoth
    Posts: 3,886
    On the other hand this year is the year where we get some expansion. I’m trying to allow for old favorites too, and I’m happy to not reinvent the wheel, but we hadn’t even done HYFRYDOL before June, in five years here. So obviously that had to be rectified.
  • novusgordo
    Posts: 72
    @SponsaChristi: you're not wrong at all. For example, we sing Mass VIII instead of Mass XI. (If Mass II were familiar for our congregation, I'd likely program that, but it really isn't.)
    Thanked by 1SponsaChristi
  • SponsaChristi
    Posts: 904
    but we hadn’t even done HYFRYDOL before June, in five years here. So obviously that had to be rectified.

    Absolutely. If there’s one hymn that gets people in the pews singing, it’s Hyfrydol. You can never have too much Hyfrydol. It’s good for what ails you.

    Especially if it has music particular to that day - people grow to know it and love it and look forward to it. It enables their ability to participate. It emphasizes the seasonal nature of our liturgical year.

    Do you still feel that way if it’s stuff like “All Are Welcome”, “Table of Plenty”, etc? I made the mistake of discovering Flogging Molly’s rendition of, “Whistles the Wind”, which sounds exactly like the chorus of Table of Plenty, so now I can’t unhear it. “All Are Welcome” just irritates me for personal reasons.