And I'd be curious how likely congregations are to follow these schools when singing the chants of the Ordinary from the Kyriale.
1. Equalist
2. Old Solesmes
3. Mensuralist
4. Proportionalist
5. Solesmes as modified by Mocqereau
6. Solesmes as it is done today at Fontgomblaut
From the adiastematic neumes, and one needs a duplex or triplex edition to do so, or an edition with added rhythmic signs—as you said, "reflecting someone else's palaeography."Fair enough, but from which editions? In the usual old editions, there are no formal longs and shorts, of course. Do you mean, then, from the Triplex? Or am I missing something obvious?
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.