When disaster strikes, the Church must step UP, not BACK!
well, there's our Bishop, right on cue.
Pray with your hands by doing useful things.
the argument that it's healthier to hand someone something is based on nothing.
“This office would like to clearly communicate that a parish cannot ban the reception of Holy Communion on the tongue, nor may an Ordinary or Extraordinary minister refuse a person requesting Holy Communion on the tongue.
[Cf: Redemptionis Sacramentum 92. “Each of the faithful always has the right to receive Holy Communion on the tongue at his choice.”]”
I can sanitize my hands as I enter the church but after twenty minutes of intermittently touching the pew or seat (on weekdays) or those and the hymnbook for forty minutes (on Sundays) the effect of that cleaning on my hands will be negligible.
Please feel free to refer anyone to the following CDC website:
https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/prepare/prevention.html
which gives the current best understanding of the virus and its transmission modes.
The short answer is that it appears that respiratory transmission, through aerosolized particles, is a likely common mode of transmission, but that it requires:
1. An aerosol source - a coughing or sneezing person who is infected
2. Reasonably close proximity to the source - the estimate is about 6 feet. Beyond that, it appears the particle fall to the ground.
3. Being in the same place as the source at the same time - see above. Compare to measles which can hang around in the air for a long time after the person spreading it is gone.
[I asked if the statement that airborne transmission is not likely were "unquestionably true,.....all the way down to ....., a malicious lie"]
Dissecting the question, I think the safe answer is “mostly false”. In the vast majority of cases we don’t know exactly what mode of transmission led to the infection. Respiratory secretion-to-surface-to-hand-to-face transmission is probably a common pathway, but so is respiratory transmission in close quarters, so it would be bad advice to suggest that taking precautions against airborne transmission is unnecessary. You didn’t ask about masks, but regular surgical masks are not effective because the particles are too small to be blocked by them although someone already sick would see some of their secretions trapped by such a mask when the cough. We need N95 masks when we look after patients in respiratory isolation because the air gaps in the fabric of the mask and the seal-fit to the face prevent the passage of the respiratory particles.
pretend isolation is not going to halt the spread of the virus. Either we do this correctly as communities and as a nation or it's all wasted effort.
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.