How many Hymnals/Pew?
  • With Advent just around the corner and the OCP hymnal/missal changeover that comes with it, I’m curious how many of the same hymnals/missals you average per pew?

    My church has so many different books in the pews, one of which was issued by the CCCB, but never used (some small red book that newcomers grab thinking the hymns are in it), yet there’s only two hymnals per large pew, and one per smaller pew. This isn’t enough. If I had a dollar for every time I had to grab a hymnal from another pew to give to someone in the same pew as me who grabs the red book wanting to sing...
    Thanked by 1CHGiffen
  • Richard MixRichard Mix
    Posts: 3,042
    We have three racks holding two hymnals each in pews that might accommodate 10-12 when the church is crowded.
  • We have three racks holding two hymnals each in pews that might accommodate 10-12 when the church is crowded.

    So roughly one hymnal/two people?
  • wren
    Posts: 14
    We have a missal every other chair, plus some extras.
  • AbbysmumAbbysmum
    Posts: 229
    Our pews hold 6 adults comfortably, or 8-10 children, depending on their ages. We also have side pews that hold 4 squished adults.

    We have one upper hymnal holder on the back of the pew in front that holds the books verticle, and one underneath the seat in front, holding the books horizontally. There is this pairing at each end of the long pew (the ones that hold 6 adults). Each end of the pew generally has

    1 Introit Hymns for the Church Year
    2 or 3 of the aforementioned red books, as we do actually sing some of the hymns and Ordinaries out of it
    2 CBW3s
    Usually just 1 Glory & Praise, the ooooooold edition
    those are all in the uppers, plus a random assortment of prayer cards, Latin prayer sheets, Communion prayers etc.

    The lower thingy almost universally has 3 St. Michael's Hymnals, which are new to us in the past 2-3 years, so still in good condition.

    So we have lots of books, just not a ton of any one book.
  • I’m trying to determine if I’m being too much if I put in a request that they give us more than two hymnals for 10 people/pew.
  • AbbysmumAbbysmum
    Posts: 229
    I don't think so. Ideally, you want a book every 2 people. Beyond that, sharing is nearly impossible. Not every one will sing, but you can invoke the "Spirit of Vatican II" stating you want everyone to have full and active participation, and therefore should have access to a book?
  • If you're using books, ideally you should have 1 per person.

    Ok .. not everyone will use one, but for a 10-person pew, at least 7 books. (Unless you have very sparse attendance and almost never 10 people in a pew).
  • a_f_hawkins
    Posts: 3,710
    I’m trying to determine if I’m being too much sic if I put in a request that they give us more than two hymnals for 10 people/pew.
    If that is hymnals with music as well as words, I think so. How many in your congregation can read music? The weight of the book will put off many people. Congregations in England expect words only editions in the pew, and perhaps a melody edition in a rack somewhere.
  • Ok .. not everyone will use one, but for a 10-person pew, at least 7 books. (Unless you have very sparse attendance and almost never 10 people in a pew).

    My pew only had one hymnal in it on the Feast of All Saints. The lady next to me wanted to sing, but grabbed the wrong book because there were no other hymnals in the pew. I ended up reaching over the pew in front of me to take the hymnal from another pew to give to her.
  • Cmanfro
    Posts: 34
    On the same topic, would anyone share…. WHO does the great, annual ‘hymnal-switch-out’ in your parishes?
    In our place, this process involves:
    *Taking the covers OFF the current hymnal;
    *Gathering these 450 books & hauling them to the dumpster;
    *Unpacking the new shipment & placing the covers ON;
    *Finally distributing them throughout the church.
    Asking for a friend •_•
  • On the same topic, would anyone share…. WHO does the great, annual ‘hymnal-switch-out’ in your parishes?


    At one time our MD made all the choir members do it after choir practice. I loathe those covers. Such a PITA.

    Now it just happens by some sort of magic or hymnal fairy.
  • AnimaVocis
    Posts: 255
    I have the music class of our parochial school help me with that process. With 8-12 kids, it takes about 45 minutes to gather up the missalettes and put new ones in place.

    We do about 650 BB missalettes in that 45 min.
  • ServiamScores
    Posts: 3,451
    In every church I've ever been in that had hymnals, there was one per slot, or two if they were double-wide slots. The exception being churches that have more than one book, in which case each double slot would get one of each. I've also seen the pew backs stuffed with hymnals, and disposable missals at the ends of the pews.

    Part of the problem with hymnals (and worship aids) is that you need to have more than get used at any given time. It's about proximity and access. You don't want people to not have them close to hand when they want to pick them up. That means you have to over fill to some degree.

    For my part, (forgive me, Lord) I don't like sharing hymnals. If I'm going to be singing, I want to be holding whatever it is and have it in front of me so I can sing well. It always irks me when there aren't enough and I have to split it with someone of a different height or singing ability, because then it's awkward. And you'll end up holding all the weight out for someone who seems non-commital anyway. If it's my wife and I in a pinch, no problem. But beyond that, no, thank you. I've been known to grab hymnals from other pews whenever there weren't enough for the people sitting in our row.

    As for switchovers, I second what's been said above. Another tactic: when we have to swap out our seasonal pew cards (missa xvii for Advent & Lent) the pastor will ask people to grab them all after the last mass and put them at the ends of the pews to help myself and other volunteers collect them. That is a MASSIVE help. It takes people 2 seconds in their pews, but saves us a ton of effort. I have also conscripted the choir at the end of rehearsal before. They are usually happy to help, God love them!