Did Catholics once sing a different version of Nearer, My God, to Thee?
For nearly seventy years, American Catholic hymnals replaced Sarah Adams' famous text with a unique Sacred Heart adaptation that reshaped the hymn into a powerful prayer of devotion and reparation.
Join me this month as we uncover this forgotten chapter of Catholic hymnody and explore how one of Christianity's most beloved melodies became a vehicle for catechesis through melody and Eucharistic faith.
Thank you. I am American, not of the British Isles, but I've long believed that the achingly plaintive HORBURY is a far finer tune than BETHANY, fine enough as BETHANY is itself. And for the Sacred Heart, an achingly plaintive register is apt.
This is an extremely interesting and well-documented article about Nearer My God to Thee. I did not know about the Catholic version with the Sacred Heart verses. I noted yesterday that the CREDO hymnal includes this hymn, although not the Catholic verses. Certainly this is a very appropriate hymn for funerals.
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.