I have been envious of my protestant organist friends because they have hymnals that they can practice sight reading out of because they have SATB instead of just the soprano notated. I have only ever seen one Catholic hymnal with SATB and as far as I am aware it is not for sale. Why is it that so few catholic hymnals include the ATB? And where should I go to buy myself a solid hymnal for sight reading and general use in my life as an organist? I don't feel like writing harmonizations for all of them.
While it's true that most Catholic hymnals, in their pew editions, have just the melody line, every hymnal that I'm aware of is also available in a choir edition (typically hardbound) and an organist edition (typically spiral-bound), both of which contain the full SATB harmonizations. If you want a book to practice from, I'd recommend, say, the
Organ/Choir Book (SPIRAL BOUND – this is a two-volume set)
of the St. Michael Hymnal, 5th edition (see here).
If you're not averse to printing out millions of sheets of paper, there are tons of hymns available for free here.
The best hymnal for practicing sight reading is the one you don’t pay for.
If you have an iPad/tablet you can read off of, OCP has a lot of its accompaniment parts you “preview” at no cost to you. Here’s the list of all the music for the 2025-2026 season (which has a great new traditional hymns and Latin “chant” in it: https://www.ocp.org/en-us/missals/TM/todays-missal
I have digitized the ultimate SATB arrangements which come from the 1940 episcopal hymnal. The voice leading is all spot on. I would not use anything else for hymnody. PM me and you can download it.
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.