In 1967, American Catholic church musicians imitated the Kingston Trio. In 1977, they imitated Peter, Paul, and Mary. In 1987, they imitated James Taylor. In 1997, they imitated Judy Collins. In 2007, they imitated U2.
In a few years, when the current rock praise'n'worship fad goes by, what past-its-prime pop act will they imitate then?
Feel free to offer your own ideas about the pop archetypes for trendy church music. I know my picture here isn't complete. It doesn't reflect the influence of e.g., country rock on the charismatic movement.
New 'Song and Sacrament' curriculum from Saint Spiritus Aetas:
TRD 617 Sing Like Tom Waites [basses only, please] TRD 719 Bono for Presiders TRD 821 Florence Foster Jenkins and Musical Democracy in the Liturgy TRD 923 Pluck and Praise: Guitar Masses are Evergreen TRD 618 Eco-Liturgy TRD 720 Youth Liturgy: The Liturgical Thought of Your Early Adolescent Children TRD 822 Power Chant TRD 924 Grunge Masses
Just barely a baby-boomer--I've been hearing about Mrs. Jenkins since high school. Baltimore's Center Stage theatre currently has in production a play called Souvenir about Mrs. J http://www.centerstage.org/production.php?prodID=46
In line with the many child-named charities (Jerry's Kids, Jimmy Fund, etc.), I believe we should have 'Florence's Children' for all those cantors, leaders of song, liturgical animators, choir members, etc. who continue the grand tradition of musico-aesthetic carnage brought to perfection by FFJ. Of course, the humor will be partially lost here, since Mrs. J was an extreme and extremely rare exception to the high quality of professional singing in New York. 'Florence's Children' are as ludicrous, but sadly not as rare.
Latest issue of ACDA's CHORAL JOURNAL has an interview with Brubeck about his sacred choral catalog, and his relationship with the Catholic Church and culture specifically. It's kind of like reading interviews with Anne Rice after her two recent Jesus the Lord novels. You want to commend, but there's a little too much invention and speculation in the art and the believer.
"Sing of the Lord's goodness" is written in 1949, (in Gather). The composer, Earnest Sands, could not have thought of singing this song at the mass when he wrote it? Are there many songs of this kind of style already sung somewhere before Vatican II ?
Leona Anderson, a performer of the 1950s comparable to Mrs. Jenkins, left us some amazing recordings! On the other hand, she did bill herself as "the world's worst singer", so she knew her act was shtick.
I have a "FFJ' reincarnated in my choir right now. Unfortunately, she was already on the cantor schedule when I took over, and I have never been able to totally 'ex' her from cantoring. Thank goodness I have enough good sops to sing over her most of the time. I have fondest memories of being introduced to FFJ on old records back when I was singing in 'The Lost Colony' for two summers under a guy who loved her!
Donna Swan
Sorry, you are right. It has letter 'b' before 1949 in Scatter, means born. I didn't pay attention to that before. Thanks. (whew! I was a bit worried about that.)
Oh, please don't let it be Celtic. This is my major instrumental repertoire and the thought of pseudo-Celtic makes me cringe. At least we didn't get a penny whistle effect after "Titanic" or "Lord of the Rings." Wait - based on the time lag, it's probably coming soon to a "young people's Mass" near you.
Wow, this is so neat to see talk of Jenkins. I used to listen to her records all the time as a kid. Couldn't get enough of it. Had the album and everything.
"chonak CommentTime1 hour ago
Leona Anderson, a performer of the 1950s comparable to Mrs. Jenkins, left us some amazing recordings! On the other hand, she did bill herself as "the world's worst singer", so she knew her act was shtick."
If you are old enough to remember the 1960s - and yes, I know the saying that if you remember the sixties, you were not really there - there was another who really was the worst singer of all time. Mrs. Miller, formally known as Mrs. Elva Miller.
Oh MJB, you have to get out more; though I suspect you were joking about the "No, not the Celtic!" Once we all got over RIVERDANCE, it was only natural back in 98/99 that GIA had (Rev.) Liam Lawton and John Bell, and I remember some really earnest "Irish" kids performing at the St. Louis NPM around that time as well.... Just let me have m' Tannahill Weavers singing "Jock Stewart" and I'll be leaving you in peace. I do have a vintage British Song textbook compiled by C.V. Stanford that contains all these great tunes from the isles. Want me to bring it to Chicago?
She sang popular songs originally released by other artists, and "her 'Downtown' single reached the Billboard Hot 100 singles chart in 1966, peaking at #82."
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.