coherent yet varietal
he allowed me a lot - Propers, good music, Chanting kids till he became aware that ANY natural change of demographic or seasonal attendance or even cataclysmic changes in area jobs market- he really sure that the High Music that is so annoying him personally, would be the only reason of collection' reactions.
A desire for variety implies to me that someone wants to be entertained. It's not interesting enough as it is, so more variety is demanded.
That is clearly a red flag that I needed to resign for my own sake.
1. The pastor is going to want his likes (right or wrong) and preferences, and expect that since he is pastor, he has a right to this.
Bottom line, it is the pastor who is responsible for what happens. The buck stops with him. His up-lines can write all fine documents they want, his sheep can do all the study they want (in theology, sacred music, finance, plumbing, whatever) - but he's the one who makes the final call.
And the ones still learning often make more decisions than their wiser brethren would.
As it happens, I have visited the parish which the original poster is writing about.
At the Sunday Mass, the priest's homily consisted of a 17-minute harangue, with a sustained tone of anger throughout, followed by his attempt to sing an inspirational song
For example: vowed religious are expected to pledge obedience in all they do, and obey the instructions re assignments and work, but in what sense are lay people expected to do so?
Certainly, and not only in the developed world, the days are past when a priest was the exclusive source of doctrinal information. Today, most educated Catholics can find out for themselves what the Church teaches or regulates on any topic.
Yet this extra knowledge should be an aid to mutual understanding rather than a weapon of discordance and the attitude should always be one of construction rather than confrontation.
I've said as much to many pastors, and never been dismissed.
and probably never thoughtthat the song might actually be somewhat annoying.
Then he sang a patriotic song, accompanying himself at an electronic piano.
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.