I read on another site this morning that 90% of church music composed these days is poor. The writer opined that 90% of church music composed two hundred years ago was also poor and, thankfully, is never heard these days.
My fear about public domain sites is that some (or even, much) of the music judged by history to be inferior is now being rediscovered.
Pietro Yon's Mass of the Shepherds is an uninspired piece, undeserving even to be called "second rate." It died in the Church's use and memory many decades ago. Keep it dead, please.
LOL! I never heard of the Mass of the Shepherds until a friend told me about it recently, but since then a priest friend referred to it with the same degree of antipathy and recalled that it was sung every Christmas by the choir at his parish from time immemorial. I think it's rather charming and a judicious use might be okay from time to time.
(Quite frankly, I'm so tired of the Mass of the Angels that I was looking for an easy alternative mass setting for this Christmas.)
I guess music touches each of us differently. For example, when I listen to the "Agnus Dei" from Mass of the Shepherds, I don't hear uninspired. This is the Mass that our choir requested to sing, as well as a prelude "Gesu Bambino." http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xlS3KoMG1xY
Advent First Religious Suite for Organ (1943) 1. Prelude (Rorate Coeli) 2. Introit (Veni Emmanuel) 3. Offertory. Veni Domine (Hymn for Peace) 4. Communion (Ave Maria) 5. Finale. Toccata on the Gregorian Hymn "Creator alme siderum"
"some (or even, much) of the music judged by history to be inferior is now being rediscovered" . I refer you to Charles Burney's General History of Music, the chapters on the Renaissance in particular. Music gets rejected by history for all kinds of reasons, not all of them connected to quality. Much 19th c. church music in particular is considered "bad" nowadays. Some is considered too sentimental and secular-sounding for worship. Some is dull and derivative. Some is considered "bourgeois" ("you say that like it's a bad thing") And some is gold. How will we know unless we look with fresh and critical eyes?
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.