Solesmes Advent
  • JenniferGM
    Posts: 59
    I was looking for a simple cd that contained the chant propers for all 4 Sundays of Advent. Solesmes has a collection of their older recordings that fits the bill, http://www.solesmes.com/GB/editions/disques.php?cmY9MzQ4 but Paraclete Press will not be carrying it this Advent.

    Has anyone ordered from Solesmes or another place to get Solesmes besides Paraclete? Is it difficult for exchange? Costly? shipping take too long?

    Thanks for any help! As I don't read French, I'm a bit slow to pull the trigger.
  • fp
    Posts: 63
    Amazon carries it.......
  • JenniferGM
    Posts: 59
    So it does! I did a search yesterday, and all that came up was German or British Amazon links, so hence my question. I did look!

    But thanks. This helps me quite a bit!
  • johndhorton
    Posts: 6
    If you don't mind purchasing from the SSPX, their Schola Bellarimina from Belgium has an Advent only CD available which is part of their series of CDs of the Propers and Ordinary of the Mass for the liturgical year. The Schola Bellarimina is adult male voices only (Pope St. Pius X's musical legislation requires that male voices be preferred in the singing of the Propers of the Mass) with organ accompaniment. This is the most beautiful setting of the Propers and Ordinary because I find a capella chant very boring and most singers can not stay on pitch without the organ. You would be ordering through the Angelus Press in Kansas City MO area which is the publishing arm of the SSPX in the USA. The list price is $42.50. See: http://angeluspress.org/Audio-Video/chant/Chant-CD-Vol-1-Advent

    John D. Horton
    Colt, Arkansas, USA
  • ronkrisman
    Posts: 1,394
    Pardon me, johndhorton, for seeking some further clarification. Do I understand correctly that you are recommending that Musica Sacra Forum contributors and readers, rather than purchasing the above-referenced Solesmes recording, instead support the schismatic SSPX by purchasing for $42.50 plus shipping and handling a 2-CD set of Advent season "propers and ordinary" (?) which you personally consider to be the "most beautiful setting" because the chants on said CD's are not sung a cappella, a form of performance which you consider to be boring? And since, in your opinion, "most singers can not stay on pitch without the organ," do you know if the "Schola Bellarimina" [sic], which performs on the Angelus Press CD's, is able to stay on pitch without the organ?
    Thanked by 4jpal Spriggo Adam Wood CHGiffen
  • Adam WoodAdam Wood
    Posts: 6,477
    the schismatic SSPX


    But it says right there on the website that they have "an unswerving commitment to orthodoxy and the Magisterium of the Roman Catholic Church."

    I'm so confused. I may never be able to trust the internet again....
  • ronkrisman
    Posts: 1,394
    Be not confused. The ad copy, I'm sure, was posted on the internet before Bishop Fellay publicly thanked God in Kansas City for preserving the SSPX from full communion with said Roman Catholic Church.
  • CharlesW
    Posts: 11,978
    Hey, I am eastern Christian. There have been times we were Orthodox, and times we were Catholic. There have been times I wish we were more Orthodox. LOL. It isn't a perfect world or church. Today's schism is tomorrow's reunion.
    Thanked by 1Jahaza
  • matthewjmatthewj
    Posts: 2,700
    Yes... we should pray for our brethren to return to regularized status, and support good music projects. Or am I a bad person for supporting the Anglicans and buying their CDs?
  • CharlesW
    Posts: 11,978
    No, you are not a bad person. I have often thought that we could learn a lot from the Anglicans.
  • chonakchonak
    Posts: 9,215
    It's possible to be too scrupulous about such things.

    Evidently Solesmes has no problem working with a non-Catholic lay monastic community as their US distributor (Paraclete).

  • JenniferGM
    Posts: 59
    I think Solesmes was duped and now stuck with a contract.

    I don't like to support SSPX, and perhaps I am too scrupulous. But this is a current schism in the making, so my money goes to support that cause, which I don't agree. I am praying for a return, not a complete break.

    Anglican break is centuries' old and so spread it, so it's quite different in my mind.
  • chonakchonak
    Posts: 9,215
    Duped? Whoa: are you just speculating there?

    I think we have a commandment against making baseless accusations.

    Solesmes has had the same distributor for about 30 years, so I doubt they're locked in by a contract. And, yes, for the sake of full disclosure, Paraclete started selling CMAA books this year, so we do have a business relationship with them.

    As for the SSPX, the Church hasn't formally declared them schismatic yet -- though the de facto condition has been there a long time.
  • JenniferGM
    Posts: 59
    Yes, just speculating. Sorry. I wonder if there was a language problem originally.

    I said "schism in the making" which doesn't mean I've declared it so. But because many of the sacraments have been declared either illicit or invalid it's a lot of indication of going down that path.
  • chonakchonak
    Posts: 9,215
    I wonder if Solesmes made a deal with a non-Catholic distributor because nobody else in the US was interested in doing it in the 1970s (or whenever they made the deal).
    Thanked by 2Adam Wood Robert
Add a Comment