I've had a few discussions recently, inside and outside of my parish walls, which have led me to reflect on this topic.
What is it that congregations know how to sing ... and more importantly, how do they know it?
Obviously, all of the music that "congregations know" was new at some point.
How did they learn it?
Perhaps us DM's ought to stop being so weak about this. All of the hymns that our congregations are familiar with were new at one point in time.They are familiar because of their repetition ... and this happened over decades and/or centuries.
If the text is good and the music is good, USE IT! If the congregation doesn't sing it during that first week, use it for a second week! Use it for a third! Use it for a fourteenth! Whatever it takes ... but isn't familiarity the key here?
And, how do we establish that? By constant use of good materials.
YES!!! Furthermore, it isn't a matter of what the congregation know, it's a matter of what people in the congregation know. And the people in the congregation are usually not monolithic in that regard. Besides, there's nothing remotely difficult about most traditional common practice hymns.
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.