Inv. Christus natus est + Venite : flatted ti or not?
  • DCM
    Posts: 88
    LH1983: no flat in antiphon or psalm setting
    AR2020: no flat in antiphon, flat in psalm (matching LR1895 and Liber Usualis)
    NR project restitution: flat in both

    As a matter of preference, the natural ti sounds right here (and I've been singing that way from the Liber Hymnarius for years). I've also noticed in the Nocturnale project's restitutions a strong preference for flatted ti in the fourth mode, which is baffling to me. But they're experts and I'm not.
    LH1983.jpg
    476 x 363 - 48K
    AR2020.png
    1296 x 434 - 46K
    NR2023.png
    2609 x 992 - 147K
  • monasteryliturgistmonasteryliturgist
    Posts: 512
    When I was learning Gregorian in Rome, we were taught that the flat is a modern rendition.
    Thanked by 1CHGiffen
Add a Comment