Has someone made that argument? It simply isn’t suited for a liturgy, especially Mass… I don’t consider P&W to be devotional, but to be a preferential genre in the realm of entertainment.to oppose the association of praise & worship music with the Mass on the grounds that it is devotional in character and not suited for liturgy
I don’t consider P&W to be devotional, but to be a preferential genre in the realm of entertainment.
How do you know that those rosaries are not the only thing holding back brimstone from falling from the sky or a world-wide famine, or a nuclear war? It's very likely they are the only thing keeping the veil from tearing. ("Will you spare them, Lord, but for these few?")
Pray both. Daily, if possible. One does not displace the other just as the Son would never displace his Mother nor the Mother displace her Son.Perhaps so, but whatever the rosary can do, the mass can do more.
Nor I. I also don’t enjoy “Christian music,” which I consider to be the same thing.I never found it entertaining.
Pray both. Daily, if possible. One does not displace the other just as the Son would never displace his Mother nor the Mother displace her Son.
The rosary is a good devotion. It is not on the same level as liturgy and shouldn't be attached to, or inserted into, liturgy.
If it's done by everyone all together, it's liturgy
That's an interesting formulation. Does it also apply to applause for the newlyweds?
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.