At Walsingham and throughout the Ordinariate we receive by intinction and on the tongue. This is one practice that I resent deeply. The irony is that I can go to any Roman rite parish and receive in a throne made of my hands as I always did as an Anglican, but the churches of the Anglican patrimony insist on spoon-feeding their people. This, presumably, makes them more Catholic. It could be worse - the Orthodox make a mush of the body and blood and literally do spoon-feed their people with a little spoon (whose Greek appellation I do not at this moment recall). I will echo Charles, who said -...the normal practice...for the first 400 years...
(I realise that few, if any, of my colleagues on our Forum will share my sympathies about this matter.)...the overreaction to what was an ancient and approved practice is over the top and beyond bonkers.
No Good Shepherd in heaven, or true good shepherd on earth, would require his sheep to gather in close proximity for the purpose of worshiping Him at the risk of infecting other sheep inside or outside the flock.
but if he is advising his sheep to go worship the Good Shepherd during a pandemic, he is very much in error.
against the consensus of public health officials and scientists
My comments were about music and liturgy
I am thankful for the wisdom he is showing in listening to scientists and health professionals,
in the real world, scientists and health professionals are considering real facts, real data, real science, and making the best recommendations possible to avoid a health catastrophe.
health catastrophe
In the real world us scientists make mistakes and get things wrong most of the time,
And I thought he meant the moderator.listen to the good shepherd
Yes, and that only about the physical world. However it is so easy, once you have a better grasp of a little bit of truth than most other people, to be tempted into pontificating.isn't science mostly the search for the truth..?
The mystics, holy writ, and Christian teaching, (and, perhaps, 'common sense') all are witness to the truth that God and spiritual entities are not and cannot be known or experienced by human senses. We can only experience or detect the physical world and universe in which we live and to which we are confined. Therefore all the efforts of some scientists and philosophers to prove or disprove God are in vain. They may reveal yet more wonders and complexities about the physical universe, but God remains unknowable by the senses, scientific instruments, or mathematical equations. Further, if there are sentient beings on other planets, as some propose and even suppose, they are a part of this created and fallen universe and are in need of the Christian message and sacraments. It is disappointing and sad that all suppositions about our future on earth or elsewhere, and/or that of presumed extraterrestial life do not envision the need of spiritual nourishment and God's saving grace - if we ever encounter them, and if there is a 'them'. God is known only by faith, the witness of the prophets, the scriptures, the witness of mystics, the life and resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth, and the (miraculous) love and compassion that dwell within human hearts...only about the physical world...
was an eloquent attempt to find that middle ground.
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.