The good news is that our 'share of hell' is nothing new: Here is "The Choirmaster's Burial", by Thomas Hardy, which recounts his Grandfather's funeral in 1837, though with a bit of fantasy thrown in.
He often would ask us That, when he died, After playing so many To their last rest, If out of us any Should here abide, And it would not task us, We would with our lutes Play over him By his grave-brim The psalm he liked best— The one whose sense suits “Mount Ephraim”— And perhaps we should seem To him, in Death’s dream, Like the seraphim.
As soon as I knew That his spirit was gone I thought this his due, And spoke, thereupon. “I think,” said the vicar, “A read service quicker Than viols out-of-doors In these frosts and hoars. That old-fashioned way Requires a fine day, And it seems to me It had better not be.”
Hence, that afternoon, Though never knew he That his wish could not be, To get through it faster They buried the master Without any tune.
But ’twas said that, when At the dead of next night The vicar looked out, There struck on his ken Thronged roundabout, Where the frost was graying The headstoned grass, A band all in white Like the saints in church-glass, Singing and playing The ancient stave By the choirmaster’s grave.
Too, I've known a few priests who admitted to having experienced their share of purgatory from having had to celebrate masses to the strains, thumps, and plunks of happy-clappy faux-folk and sacro-pop combos.
Not really sure that's the good news, Salieri ;-/ As many of you must already know, The Choirmaster's Burial is No. 5 of Britten's Winter Words, about 9'33'' into the recording with Peter Pears. (Oops, here it is at the start of part 2.)
It mightn't be good news, per se, but I do find some comfort in knowing that when it comes to battles with clergy or influential members of the parish, we're in good company: from people as illustrious as Bach and Mozart in major churches and cathedrals, to the basically unknown, like Tomas Hardy I, in a little parish church in the Dorset countryside.
An update: I was offered the possibility of playing one or two Saturday evenings a month, and was told I could do the Heritage Mass (which is what we had been doing before). I decided to take it (two evenings a month), for the income; if it turns out to be too much, I'll just say I can't keep doing it.
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.