Catholiics can't sing.

Carol

CGZ, that is a classy response! I feel a bit chastened, thanks!

bhcordova

Back to the title of the thread - It's not that Catholics can't sing, it's that they don't want to sing. They just want to be entertained for an hour and then go home.

Rphillips

.

davido

When I go to mass, I frequently have no desire to sing. Partly it’s the lousy music, partly it’s wrestling with toddlers, but mostly, I would rather listen and meditate.

I think the reality of the mass encourages meditation more than robust singing.

Salieri

Bhcordova & davido. Thank you for your comments regarding Catholics singing at Mass. (Which I think are both correct to differing degrees in different places. And is something which ought to be discussed here. Perhaps a new thread would be good.)

Unfortunately, this thread was never actually about that: the OP used the title of Thomas Day's book as clickbait for a thread ranting about Donald Trump and immigration law, and to hurl insults at anyone who(m)(?) he thinks supports Donald Trump and/or the Republican party, even to the point of hysteria, calling them/us/whomever "Nazis".

matthewj

I'm pretty sure this forum would be a better place if we killed this thread with fire.

chonak

If I remember right, one of the points listed in the forum guidelines is that:

We do not want to be known as people who engage in pointless arguments.

Welcome to the MusicaSacra Forum!

Categories