Choir lighting
  • Don9of11Don9of11
    Posts: 708
    Our choir area in church has a low light situation in some areas and choir member's are having difficulty reading music and shifting their seating to get more light and the pastor has said it's not cost effective to add additional ceiling lights. So I've turned my attention to the Mighty Bright option which are battery operated lights that clip on a binder or music folder. I've been doing some research but thought I would ask to see if anyone had found something better for their choir member's.
  • Liam
    Posts: 5,093
    Are your choristers in pews, on risers or in chairs? Would it be logistically feasible to provide music stands with lights for those with dimness issues?
  • Don9of11Don9of11
    Posts: 708
    We are in chairs and most are elderly so the less obstacles to trip over the better but thank you for that suggestion. A floor layout of the church and choir area can be found here https://stpaulakron.org/parish/basics/contactus/campus-map/

    I was thinking a lighted music binder might be good, something with LED and battery. Morning and mid-day services are not so bad because we get a lot of natural lighting but anything in the evening is rough and those seated near the wall particularly so. A wall mounted LED battery option might work to.
  • the pastor has said it's not cost effective to add additional ceiling lights


    If he'd reported that the electrician says it's not feasible, it would sound convincing. But cost-effective? How much would he want to the collection to increase by each day in order for it to be cost effective?

    I would have a word to the chair of the finance committee, to check what conditions your public liability insurance has regarding having adequate lighting.

    Also - if ceiling mounted fitted lights is not an option, what about wall mounted mains-powered lights?
  • Don9of11Don9of11
    Posts: 708
    Ceiling lights are very expensive to add and would require scaffolding to reach to replace bulbs and please I do not want to create a discussion finding fault with our pastor. The word has been given and any discussion on said ceiling lights is mute.

    I'm looking for a low tech solution, assestically pleasing for the church. Wall mounted battery operated lighting might be an option providing they produce enough light and avoid anything like mood lighting.
    Thanked by 1canadash
  • canadashcanadash
    Posts: 1,501
    We're in a similar situation. I actually find it difficult. I will be watching this thread with interest.
    Thanked by 1Don9of11
  • We have Mighty Brights, older ones with incandescent bulbs. They work well, and my singers with poorer vision do appreciate them, but they drain the batteries like you wouldn't believe. The newer LED ones might be less power-hungry, though.
    Thanked by 1Don9of11
  • Reval
    Posts: 186
    I have seen these used effectively in an orchestra setting. I know you are concerned that people might trip over obstacles, but these stand lights are battery-operated, so at least you wouldn't have cords.
    https://www.arialights.com/prod_rechargeable.html

    With cord (without battery):
    https://www.arialights.com/prod_plug_in.html
  • for those with dimness issues?


    I know it's not the topic of the thread, but I enjoyed this expression tremendously. It described most liturgy committees. Remember Screwtape's admonition: "Dim the lights".
  • KyleM18
    Posts: 150
    I've used non-brand name "Mighty Brights" that last me about, 30 masses. They were not brand name, so I could get a replacement pretty cheap, and they worked well.
  • francis
    Posts: 10,826
    ipads
  • Carl DCarl D
    Posts: 992
    When looking for lighting solutions for my office, I was shocked to find LED Light Strips like this. For $16 you get fifteen feet of lights that plug directly into the mains. For my office, I have them behind a piece of moulding at 7 feet from the floor, so you don't see the lights directly - they reflect off the wall and ceiling.

    With a moderately skilled carpenter, you may be able to design something that works nicely.
    Thanked by 1Jes
  • JesJes
    Posts: 576
    Okay, so we had a similar situation.
    We found an electrician in the parish who could donate some service to installing running lights on a track which he installed on the side walls behind pillars and are dimmable for those low light days. They are little LED's and work a treat. There is no harm in putting an ad in the bulletin for an electrician or lighting specialist to contact the parish. It WORKS.
  • JesJes
    Posts: 576
    Also, if you can't get a sparky from parish resources and you want a rough outback ORGANIST LIFE HACK version of @CarlD 's idea:

    If you buy a PVC Pipe (plastic plumbing pipe) the length of your stripe of lighting. Cut it in half (lengthways so you get two open crescent shaped long pipe bits), line the inner curve with aluminium foil (shiny side up) (paste it in with PVA glue or craft glue or I think you guys call it elmers glue?) Screw small holes at angles in the pipe crescent (for the cable ties to feed through.)

    If you want to hide the pipe use church wall paint or black to paint the back side of the pipe. then you can actually (with permission from your priest screw the pipe to the wall nearest your choir or into a corner behind a pillar or statue border OR you can hang them from the roof by attaching a hooks to the roof and put string in a hole at each end of the pipe. Before hanging put your LED strip of light inside the pipe and fasten with plastic cable ties

    Easiest lighting case that will spread your light way further and make those LED's way more potent.
  • JesJes
    Posts: 576
    ALSO another rough outback Life Hack for individual music stand sconces on a serious budget.

    Use smaller LED strips (battery operated) (no longer than the length of your music stand.) Make up the same PVC Pipe style light with foil but smaller, (My recommended max size would be 30cm long for both) Attach Medium-Large bulldog clips (not those small paper clip type, serious ones 4cm wide ones) to the back of the pipe (which you will definitely paint black after doing this) with a Hot Glue Gun and then clip the clips onto the music stand. The awesome thing about cable ties is that you can get rid of the old LED's if they are somehow made defunct.

    Need less power? don't use foil but keep the white inside of the pipe.
    Need less leakage? Get Blue gels from a lighting store and use Gaffa Tape to tape the Gels to the lights and use PVC Pipe Caps cut in half to attach to the end.
    Too heavy? Use a lower mm pipe diameter or less pipe with less LED length and Tape the battery pack to the back of your stand instead of inside the pipe.

    @hugh what do you think they should do?
  • canadashcanadash
    Posts: 1,501
    Oh my. I need pictures.
  • jefe
    Posts: 200
    In our 162 year old Nave, lighting has always been a problem. The church choir has a bank of six shielded 150 watt floods directly pointing down to the choir area in the loft and aimed to cover the choir only. This is adequate but very hot in summer. There is also some bleed over to the congregation. I don't conduct the church choir, but being that the loft is a flat, wood floor and walls space with no pews, only folding chairs, and coming from an orchestra background, I bought enough lightweight, black Manhasset music stands to service choir up to 28 bodies. Four of these are the 'double' choir stands with enough width to hold two choir folders side by side and any service books or hymnals you might use. These are space saving but not as flexible as the singles.
    The Compline Choirs require a different lighting strategy. Remember, it's almost dark in there especially between October and March. Since the Nave is lit only by 94 candles, the Compline Choirs need their own personal lights to see the notation and to keep the overall Nave lighting as low as possible. I bought enough recessed incandescent stand lights to service 18 bodies along with a 20 plug power strip. Since we mostly stand in a circle during Compline (there is no accompaniment except when we use hand bells) the chance of tripping on the single cord coming from the center is low. I really like the 'old time' glow of soft incandescents but a few of our Compline people don't do well in low light situations and must have two stand lights to perform. This has worked well for 8 years of our 16-18 times a year Compline. Last year my son who sings bass in the men's group recommended the two headed, two setting, battery operated, clip on, LED lights as a more flexible alternative. Skeptical, I bought a half dozen (they're fairly cheap) and gave them a test. They passed with flying colors, so i purchased another dozen. We have about half instrumentalists and half trained singers in our groups so the singers used to holding their scores in our half inch, 3 ring score binders can do same and X-out the music stand entirely. The instrumental folks, used to a stand can just clip the light on the stand. If you consider these, buy a half dozen to see if they're for you. NB: there is a long stem and a short stem version. The loft is at the rear of the Nave so we are out of sight. There is less light bleed over to the Nave as the two headed lights are focuses and directional, not flood. The only thing I don't like about the LED's is the color of the light. It's too high a Kelvin number and very blue unlike the lower K of the stand lights. However, they light only the music. I bought another dozen clip lights for our combined compline last summer. The good news is we occasionally process, in semi-darkness of course, and just add clip lights to the score binders. The result has a pixie-like parade of wobbling points of light but it gets the job done. The maximum juggle is when we process in semi-darkness holding the score binders, holding LED lights, and everyone is ringing a handbell. It sounds like '3 balls in the air' to me. The other important issue is that LED's use 1/10th the energy of incandescents. We started using our gaggle of LED music lights last summer and have never replaced or run out of battery. I'm sold. A clip on dual 2 arm LED book Reading Music Stand Light (by sunshine maker) is now $3.98 on Amazon.

    jefe
  • bhcordovabhcordova
    Posts: 1,164
    how about headlamps (mining lamps, etc.) You can get LED lights already made up that will work as headgear. They also make very cheap (about $1.00 US) LED clip on lights with a very flexible neck. Last for months.
  • Liam
    Posts: 5,093
    Headlamps: for women only, of course.... Women may not have to wear them, but non-clerical men wearing headgear in church (actually, indoors generally) is the last surviving taboo. (I do get a bit cross-eyed seeing a guy with a baseball cap on in church especially - fortunately, it's rare in that context, but more common in other indoor locations, such as restaurants - grr.....)
    Thanked by 1Spriggo
  • JL
    Posts: 171
    Perhaps the headlamp is the biretta of the 21st century. :)

    In all seriousness, I second the battery-operated stand lights. They have come to my rescue in many a dark church.
    Thanked by 1canadash