Taize chant is excellent, for Taize and its constant stream of mostly young pilgrims. It does not work well at Iona because the climate is different. It is not intended for sustaining an adult community week after week. The same could be said of the Rosary, there are circumstances where repeating the same prayer 50 or 150(200) times is appropropriate, but the Mass is not one of them. If a congregation is unused to chant you have to start with simple stuff, but then MOVE ON.
Amen.Speaking of rosaries, I still don't understand the reasoning behind the additional "mysteries" added by John Paul II, who was saintly, but whose canonization was, I believe, a popularity contest. Some of us used to call them the mundane mysteries since they were not on the level of the other fifteen.
The Theophany (the first revelation of the Most Holy Trinity to the world at the baptism of our Lord), the Transfiguration and the Last Supper are many things, but mundane is not one of them.
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.