An iconography student once said to a master, "I wish to paint a nativity icon, but all the ancient examples are different from one another. How do I know what to copy, and where do I have freedom to invent new variations?" The master answered, "Set all the ancient icons side by side. Some things will be the same in all of them. This is the canon, to which you must faithfully adhere. Other details will vary, and here you may paint something new, so long as your creativity is consistent with the spirit and intent of the old examples."
It is dangerous to mix styles and cultures without sensitive judgment as to what can go together and what cannot. As a general rule, we kept everything as simple as possible, because simplicity is compatible with every culture and style, and is always beautiful -- ornament is less forgiving.
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.