There’s nothing wrong with singing the Missal antiphons and justifying it by playing the “alius cantus aptus” trump card
[...] In the Dioceses of the United States of America there are four options for the Entrance Chant: (1) the antiphon form the Missal or the antiphon with its psalm from the Graduale Romanum as set to music there or in another setting[.]
the Missal antiphons are officially option 1, and listed even before the Graduale, at least in the United States GIRM.
there is a real danger that the Graduale will simply disappear, even in those places that want to do Propers.
haha... until they revise the translation in 10 years or more, or less....musicians can have recourse to an official, universal, English translation of the GR Propers to draw from.
I'm not convinced the church has its priorities in that order. Surely musical skill is a sine qua non; are music lessons ever really that infeasible?Sometimes understanding what the liturgy entails is more important than knowing how to read music... they can't seem to be bothered with what the Church asks us to do.
Clearly the most noticeable new departure is that of language. From now on the vernacular, not Latin, will be the principal language of the Mass. For those who
appreciate the beauty of Latin, its power, and aptness to express the sacred, substitution of the vernacular certainly represents a great sacrifice. We are losing the idiom of the Christian ages; we become like profane intruders into the literary sanctuary of sacred language; we shall lose a large portion of that wonderful and incomparable, artistic and spiritual reality, Gregorian chant. We indeed have reason for sadness and perhaps even for bewilderment. What shall we put in the place of this angelic language? We are sacrificing a priceless treasure. For what reason?
True to one's conscience one must be.
Each must be true to himself.
Nor would we wish it otherwise.
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.