Graduation Mass
  • Hello!

    My name is William, and I am an organist in Tennessee. I wanted to receive some insight concerning a high school "graduation Mass" my church is planning in May.

    What is the Church's position on these type of "theme Masses"? The powers that be want to have the graduates process in with the priest, then sing at the front of the church. I have been asked, since I will also be a graduate, if I would be interested in joining the procession.

    Now, this seems to me as putting the focus of the Mass in the wrong place, especially as this will be a Sunday Mass. I would like to know how much I should participate in this, and whether any changes in the usual music would be in order. Thank you!
  • Jani
    Posts: 441
    Hi williamjm. I can't help you, but I want to say welcome since your question went up a few hours ago and no one has answered you yet :)
    Thanked by 1williamjm
  • chonakchonak
    Posts: 9,216
    Welcome, williamjm! It's good to hear from one more young organist.

    Events like this are not unusual. Many parishes with Catholic high schools offer a "baccalaureate Mass" for graduating students. And many dioceses have annual Masses for special groups: e.g., a "blue Mass" for policemen, a "red Mass" for lawyers and judges, Masses for health-care workers, etc. Similarly, at Vatican City, the Holy See has events for special groups, often including a Mass.

    Of course, when any such Mass is celebrated, it should be conducted according to the liturgical norms. It is not unusual for lay people to be present in the entrance procession. They may include servers, readers, choir members, persons to be confirmed, etc., so adding graduates is not a big stretch. The priest celebrating the Mass enters last.

    The point about having the graduates sing raises some questions. If they are going to function as a choir for the Mass, to sing one or more pieces, then whatever they sing should be suitable for the Mass: not an entertainment song, or a song about the school.

    Have you been offered the option to play for the Mass?


    Thanked by 1williamjm
  • I am the regular organist at my church, and as this Mass will be a regular Sunday Mass, I do plan to play. I was given the option of processing in with the graduates while the synthesizer played! Not a chance of that. Thank you very much for your help with this.
  • canadashcanadash
    Posts: 1,501
    Hi William.... welcome! I was just wondering... do you often have "school" Masses? What are they like if you do? This may be a good indication if you should be concerned in advance...
  • I am home-schooled, so I have no experience with high school Masses. I was at my brother's college graduation Mass, but that is a different matter, as it was not taking the place of Sunday Mass. That is an issue that concerns me. I thought Sunday Masses are to be focused only on God. That is why we don't celebrate feast days on Sundays.
    Thanked by 1JulieColl
  • we don't celebrate feast days on Sundays.

    That is not entirely true, as certain feasts can replace Sundays in Ordinary Time, especially if there is a genuine pastoral need. I believe even in the EF the Immaculate Conception, for example, can replace the Sunday of Advent.
    Thanked by 1williamjm
  • Thank you, I stand corrected. But I don't imagine that a graduation, while a joyous occasion, attains to the rank of a feast.
  • Without getting into a very long explanation (and probably a debate,) the mass is not ONLY vertical but horizontal too. Much ink and keystrokes have been spent talking about bringing back the vertical in the mass; and that is a laudable goal. But the pendulum can swing too far in the other direction too.

    Mass is both the unbloody sacrifice AND a communal meal, and the Church has long recognized that it's proper to celebrate certain monumental moments in the lives of people at mass.

    In short: stop worrying about it. The focus of the mass will not be the graduation. The graduation will simply be celebrated at the mass. Major Catholic universities have graduation masses all the time. Highlighting it a bit at the Sunday mass will allow people to take part in it since they are not likely to attend a separate mass during the week. This isn't a big deal. Just do the best job YOU can making the music befitting of the mass.
  • My parish, unfortunately, does not have a tradition of keeping the focus on God during the Mass. The parishioners do not have a well-formed sense of what the Mass truly is. I think it more than likely undue attention will paid to the graduation, given the state of my parish.
  • CHGiffenCHGiffen
    Posts: 5,193
    Major Catholic universities have graduation masses all the time.
    And, quite often, these are on Sunday, along with commencement.
  • Liam
    Posts: 5,093
    Well, since it will be a Sunday in May, that means it will be a Sunday in Eastertide or the Solemnity of the Most Holy Trinity; the bishop would have to give permission for the use of votive propers (the votive Mass of the Holy Spirit is customary for baccalaureate Masses), otherwise you must use the propers of the relevant Sunday. The last Sunday in May is Trinity Sunday; the Sunday before that is Pentecost; the Sunday before that might be the transferred observance of the Ascension or not, depending on where you live. All that said, the traditional graduation theme of invoking the guidance of the Holy Spirit (Veni Creator Spiritus, for example) will work with the propers of most of those.
    Thanked by 1williamjm
  • canadashcanadash
    Posts: 1,501
    I am home-schooled, so I have no experience with high school Masses.


    Hug your mother. :)
  • Hug your mother. :)


    Done!
    Thanked by 2canadash JulieColl
  • William,

    Welcome to the Forum.

    Just a few points:

    1) in the Extraordinary Form, weddings, confirmations and such take place outside of Mass, but in the Ordinary Form, the rule seems to be that everything takes place within Mass, so Baptisms, Confirmations, Christmas Pageants, Quincineras, celebrations of Black History Month...... all take place there, without distinction as to which might be appropriate and which might not.

    2) The fact that this difference exists seems to be intended by the crafters of the Ordinary Form: the continued existence of a commentator, the expressions "these or other, similar, words" and the now famous "alius cantus aptus" provide plenty of grounds for "flexibility" in the Mass, so that it is hard to oppose a graduation ceremony taking place within the Mass and -- at least to the untrained eye -- overwhelming the Holy Sacrifice.

    3) PGA, with whom I nearly always disagree, has two nuances in the recent posting with which I must agree, in part. It is true that there are both horizontal and vertical aspects to the Mass, just as there are horizontal and vertical aspects to a Crucifix. How many people, seriously speaking, in your parish, are in doubt as to the existence of horizontal aspects of the Mass? Compare that to how many are in doubt as to the existence of vertical aspects of the Mass and their equal or greater importance? You may not be committing a mortal sin by participating in a graduation ceremony within Mass, but that's not the only reason to avoid it. PGA is also correct that the Mass is both a sacrifice and a meal -- but I would use the word "banquet", since it is the wedding banquet of the Lamb. Furthermore, the meal, at which we are fed spiritual food, is only possible because of the sacrifice.

    Thanked by 1williamjm
  • Thank you, Mr. Garton-Zavesky. My plan is to play the music for the Mass, but I will in no way do anything that will abet what should not be happening. I will play my music to glorify God.

    Also, do university graduation Masses take the place of regular Sunday Mass?
  • chonakchonak
    Posts: 9,216
    Just to be clear, we're not talking about a different Mass with different readings or antiphons. We're talking about a Sunday Mass that incidentally has some acknowledgement of the graduation in (for example) the homily, in the prayers of the faithful, and in the choral singing by the graduates.

    Incidentally, any Mass offered by a Catholic priest on a Sunday (including a wedding or a confirmation or whatever) fulfills the Sunday mass attendance obligation.
    Thanked by 1williamjm
  • This is a great topic! I am in the same boat. I'm a homeschooled senior and play for all the weekend Masses. Now that I'm thinking about it I don't think I'll walk up either... better to participate by playing! : )
    Thanks for all the great advice!
    Thanked by 1CHGiffen
  • melofluentmelofluent
    Posts: 4,160
    I've been somewhat confused by this thread.
    Are we speaking about a Baccalaureate Mass, or a Mass that includes an actual commencement and graduation?
  • This is to be a graduation recognition within the regular Sunday Mass, not involving the giving of diplomas. Whether it will occur or not has not been officially determined, as there has been a request to move the recognition ceremony to a reception after Mass.
  • melofluentmelofluent
    Posts: 4,160
    Generally William, that is simply known as a Baccalaureate Mass, even at the 8th or 12th grade levels in secondary schools.
    Thanked by 1williamjm
  • Thank you. However, do Baccalaureate Masses take the place of a regular Sunday Mass?
  • chonakchonak
    Posts: 9,216
    It's an informal matter and there's no rule about it.

    Probably the most correct way to handle it would be to treat the graduation recognition as a parish announcement, after the post-communion prayer. However, some priests might recognize the graduates in the homily instead, or in introductory remarks at the start of the Mass.

  • CharlesW
    Posts: 11,980
    Before I retired from teaching in a Catholic school, I would get stuck with playing for the graduation mass each year, since I am also the parish DM and organist. I played good music for those masses and did the best I could with them. I never sat with the faculty, and hid out with the organ in the loft half a block away. That worked out nicely. An hour or so later, it was over and I didn't have to fool with it for another year. The school ran into some financial difficulty and was made into a regional school rather than attached to a single parish. They handle their own graduations somewhere else, and I don't have to deal with them any more. But since it is a graduation mass, expect extraneous remarks, something a bit odd inserted somewhere in the mass, and hope there is no major craziness thrown in.
  • melofluentmelofluent
    Posts: 4,160
    No, William, the proper lessons are normative. But the celebrant may opt to change those under his provision, as I understand it.
  • I'm going to double down and state again, for the record, that I don't understand why anyone would recoil at the thought of graduates being recognized during mass.

    Every "faithful, orthodox, Latin loving, throw in whatever other meaningful adjective you want" priest that I've ever known has chosen to do this in their parish. It seems pretty clear to me that there's a long tradition of it, and it seems, again, quite normative for the Church to recognize momentous occasions in the lives of people at mass, as is the case for 50th wedding anniversaries, anniversaries of ordination, etc.

    The way some people talk about this, I wonder what they think of having masses to commemorate the bishop's 25th anniversary as bishop; after all, is any of the focus of that mass on HIM and not GOD?
    Thanked by 1melofluent
  • I really don't have a problem with the fact of having a graduation Mass per se. I attended my brother's college graduation Mass, and that was very appropriate. The regular Sunday Mass, however, is "set apart," from other Masses. Am I not correct?
  • melofluentmelofluent
    Posts: 4,160
    I think that depends upon the collaborative planning between the pastor and the principal. At our K-8, Baccalaureate Mass is one of the Sunday scheduled Masses, readings of the day, etc. Kids are gowned, but no other scripted moments other than impromptu remarks by the celebrant are accreted. That stuff is saved for the Commencement, not a liturgy.
  • PGA,

    Can you truly not see the difference between a Wedding Anniversary or Episcopal Consecration on the one hand and a high-school graduation on the other?

  • chonakchonak
    Posts: 9,216
    Let the record show that on this occasion I more or less agree with PGA. :-)

    Consider all the events that are routinely permitted to intrude upon Mass: e.g., fund-raising appeals, announcements about religious-ed programs, recognitions of wedding anniversaries, ceremonies for new religious-ed teachers or EMHCs, secular observances such as Mother's Day, etc.

    Compared to those, a word of congratulation to the graduates of the *parish's own school* is not a strange deviation.

    But the guidelines that melo mentions above are a good idea.
    Thanked by 1melofluent