I wonder if this is not a drop-dead gorgeous chant which should remain in Latin and should be known by all Catholics.
I retained the Latin "Ave Maria." So, it's not entirely an English version.
I appreciate your efforts, WJA, but I wonder if this is not a drop-dead gorgeous chant which should remain in Latin and should be known by all Catholics.
If there is to be an English version, it should stick closely to the melody of the Latin. In particular, the opening "Ave Maria" melody needs to be kept, IMO. I've sketched out a possibility. Perhaps others could lend their thoughts about refining it, if they think such a setting is desirable.
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.