Donde Hay Caridad y Amor Altissimo Senor O Cruz Fiel y Venerable Cantemos Al Amor De Los Amores Tu Reinaras Cien Ovejas Una Espiga Amemonos de Corazon Un Mandamiento Nuevo Todo Lo Que Tengo
It is said that Pescador de Hombres was Pope John Paul II's favorite song. This could be apocryphal. However, despite its apparent overuse, I think it's a very worthy composition that is akin to genuine folk music.
However, just because Blessed John Paul II liked it, that does not necessarily render it fit for the Mass. The piece focuses more on the self. Interestingly enough, this is the same Pontiff who called for the purification of liturgical music. I respect that this is your favorite song, but I cannot recommend it for liturgical use.
Pescador de Hombres is not my favorite song. However, I know it engages Spanish-speaking congregations. Compared to a lot of the drivel that passes for liturgical music, this composition is musical and possesses noble simplicity.
Some of my favorite songs were originally in Italian and have been translated to Spanish by Spanish-speaking fans: I.Passioni's El Señor es mi Eterno Pastor Marco Frisina's beautiful liturgical works for SATB: Heme aqui, Quien nos separará, Yo contigo iré, Madre Confianza Nuestra, Nuestra gloria es la Cruz, Oh Hostia Santa, etc.
Plus I like: C.E. Haugel's Como una cierva A. Taule's El Señor es mi luz A Mejia's Himno Cristológico and Cantico de Maria Alma de Cristo, by Joseph Gelineau, originally in French Alianza nueva, by M.P. de la Figuera and L. Deiss Véante mis ojos, poetry of Saint Teresa of Avila set to music by F. Pedrell
Wow, can we please not fight about the tastes of such a great pope? Keep in mind his great support of sacred music (despite everyone basically ignoring him... but he wasn't the first, and surely not the last, to have that experience).
I don't know the song, but if it is, as chonak says, a "Jesus & me" type of song, then why wouldn't Blessed JPII love it?
And who says that he loved it for liturgical use? Maybe he loved it for personal devotion.
With all due respect, get over yourself, benedictgal.
Dios esta Aqui Entre Tus Manos Te Ofrecemos Padre Nuestro Senor Tu eres el Pan Te Presentamos Zamba del Grano de Trigo Quien es Ese? Juntos Como Hermanos Caminare Adios Reina del Cielo Santa Maria del Amen Jesus es mi Luz Senor Quien Puede Entrar? Alabare
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.