I have been doing this piece with choirs since 1976. I have my own arrangement which I will put up. Love this piece. In fact, I composed the ordinary using it as a musical theme to be used for the Christmas season.
I'm well acquainted with the original (2nd movement chorale from BWV 65 "Sie werden aus Saba alle kommen", where the text is:
Die Kön'ge aus Saba kamen dar, kamen dar Gold, Weihrauch, Myrrhen brachten sie dar. Alleluja, alleluja!
Bach, in his wisdom and as his custom, only used this single verse. The overall setting (harmonization) seems more like that of a stately procession (as reflected in the video clip), but then Bach was a master at adapting a melody to the situation at hand. I agree that, as a hymn, the Praetorius setting fits the original "Puer natus in Bethlehem" better.
Ralph, the last I leaned against a pillar it cost me money...at Chartres you are allowed to take pictures. But if you lean against a pillar or the wall, a men runs up and you have to pay for a ticket to do "supported" photographs...a tripod fee even without a tripod.
In 1969 you could drive underneath the Eiffel Tower and park there. A man comes up and collects a fee...it's not for parking, its for insurance against the tower falling on your car...those days are long gone.
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.