Helping people be receptive to chant
  • Carl DCarl D
    Posts: 992
    My pastor is fairly supportive of the chant that we do at Mass, and wants to see us continue. He's also sensitive, of course, to various complaints he gets from parishioners:
    * It sounds depressing
    * I don't know Latin
    * I can't sing this stuff
    * This is taking us back to the Dark Ages

    These are typical reactions that I'd expect from people who have been solidly ingrained with 1970s liturgical music, in a church built in the early 1980s. Father will be doing his part to catechize everyone about the upcoming changes, but he's challenged me to help them understand the beauty and the value of this sacred music.

    Which is what I'm asking for help with today.

    How can I best use the short "practice time" before Mass to help people to be more receptive to this? I help them to get more familiar with the unfamiliar music, of course, but the question is: What should I SAY? Falling back on "pride of place" and the endorsement of distant authorities in Rome won't make much of an impact with this crowd.

    Ideas?
  • If we didn't know better, we might think the above complaints were coming from some sort of extreme Protestants! Certainly not Catholics!
    How refreshing, though, to encounter a priest who is concerned about those people who DO like chant and their Catholic heritage.
  • Liam
    Posts: 4,955
    This treasury music is their birthright heritage as Catholics, as much as Martin Luther's hymns are for Lutherans, Russian chant is for the Russian Orthodox, Gospel songs are for revivalist congregations, and a cantor's Hebrew chant is for Jews, et cet. All religious communities with a long history and that use music in their worship appear to develop a distinctive musical brand, and this body of music is what is distinctively ours. You are trying to empower the faithful in your community to cease being strangers with what is theirs by right. They should no more be strangers to [insert name of your basic chant of choice] than Lutherans should be strangers to A Mighty Fortress Is Our God or Jews to the Kol Nidre.

    1. Don't be guilty of plodding chant. People may associate chant with plodding versions that were once balefully common. (If your church's acoustic is not resonant, however, there's not much you can do to make chant sound as inviting as it should be.)
    2. Chant doesn't have to be only in Latin. It may be good to avoid having chant being experienced only in its Latin form. (You may have to teach people how to pronounce the Latin, and if it's not an obvious text from the ordinary, be sure to provide translations as a basic gesture.)
    3. Really? Children are well known for taking to simple chant like fish to water. (You might start by choosing chants that can be sung well by your most intimidated choristers. And, given the ever-growing musical illiteracy among people these days, you may have to teach by example - antiphonal repitition, et cet.)
    4. No, actually, it's not.

    Most of all, don't preach at them about the value of this music. You should be aligning yourself with them, rather than over them, as it were.
  • Liam
    Posts: 4,955
    In other words, come at this from the personal, sociological level, rather that from What The Documents Say. When you have to resort to authority as a first measure, you've lost.
  • All of Liam's advice is sage.
    Also, since your priest is on your side, you might ask him to say a few encouraging words to the people before making your presentation.
    If they have no doubt that their pastor really wants chant, their attitude will be much more positive.
    Teach chant by singing, never with an instrument. People need to hear the sounds, words, diction and rhythms that they are supposed to sing with their voices.
    Emphasize how the chant exists to illuminate the text and follows the rhythm of the words.
    Tell them, show them, how joyful and worshipful it is.
    Help them to realize that chant is a seminal aspect of their Catholic culture, of being Catholic.
  • Liam
    Posts: 4,955
    "Teach chant by singing, never with an instrument"

    YES!
  • Another approach is not to talk to them about it at all, just sing it and invite them to sing it after you, with a word of two about the meaning of the words...in other words, the less you say, the less they have to complain about.

    This is how the vernacular Mass music was introduced. "Today we are singing" seems to have succeeded.

    But all this is wasted if the pastor does not thank them for participatingm even if they do not.
  • Offer an evening or Saturday 'chant explotation' event, with many schola members in attendance. Listen to recordings, watch some CCW clips, most importantly sing-
    dive into a few rich chant hymn texts, and work through part or all of an Ordianry. Meet hostility with a warm exuberance about such a great form of prayer.

    Complainers can come and be won over,
    or not won over. But they can't complain that chant is being implemented without an opportunity to reach out to them.
  • And if no one except the schola comes, it's still not a waste of time!
  • Also, it is good to teach beginners right off to sing something that they absolutely cannot fail to sing.
    A good place to start is from the corpus of simple Gregorian hymns.
    One that is almost sure to become a favourite is Jesu dulcis memoria.
    Teach it to them in Latin and in English (using G.H. Hopkins' inimitable translation).
    This is a superb communion meditation hymn, as is Adoro te devote (using preferably the translation in the 1940 - Catholic translations of this tend to be rather botched and clumsy, usually getting the metre wrong where a podatus or such should be employed on a single syllable).
    People seem automatically to like these hymns. You can then move to parts of the ordinary (avoiding mass XVIII, which is for requiems).
    Also - begin using psalm tones exclusively for the gradual psalm, composing your own simple modal responds if necessary. (I have a number that I could send you.)
  • francis
    Posts: 10,678
    Talking about chant probably won't be very effective. Put something in the bulletin like "did you know?" and perhaps a paragraph or two about the patronage of sacred music or something like that.
  • jgirodjgirod
    Posts: 45
    Did you know that some monks/religious/nuns became depressive and it was eventually found out that it was because chant had been suppressed? So I don't believe chant sounds depressive, rather it should bring an overwhelming peace of mind. Now there are people who always are in a rush and can't relax (type A personality); these don't like calm, but it would do so much good to them (and to their heart).

    Now for the Dark Ages, what a cliché! It took of course centuries for the Church to turn barbarians into civilized men, but if that succeeded, it is that the Church used the good means: schools, beautiful churches, liturgy including chant and above all the saintliness of its members.
  • Chrism
    Posts: 868
    The effect of chant on the humors is said to depend on its Mode (scroll down for chart). Try Mode VIII chants if you want to cure people's depression.
  • Adam WoodAdam Wood
    Posts: 6,451
    So THAT'S what everyone meant when they you should use humor to get your choir to show up on time!
  • Carl DCarl D
    Posts: 992
    Thanks, everyone, for the insightful and generous comments!

    Last year I did a "introduction to chant" workshop for the parish, and it worked out quite well. I'm going to repeat that in a couple of weeks. Granted, it only speaks to the people who are OPEN to chant, but brick by brick...

    The pastor is supportive but not overly complimentary. I'll take what I can get, but I don't expect him to say more than 10 words about the music at the Mass. I tested that with him yesterday, and didn't sense that he wants to personally take a more visible role - he's worried about the larger issues of backlash against other changes he's making, and will need to make in connection with the new Missal.

    I've been using various Chabanel psalms for a couple of years now, and have been composing my own Alleluias based upon the Latin text in the Gregorian Missal. I try to have a mixture of traditional hymns, Latin chants, and English chants. This year I'm going to attempt incorporating the Communion chant of the day, albeit with some simplifications for our schola.

    I have occasionally put articles in our bulletin but it's hard to know how much impact that has - the only thing people ever comment about is trivial errors.

    Thanks all, and keep the suggestions coming!