This is just me going through and characterizing them. I'm not making any votes.
Christmas: Angels from the Realms of Glory Angels We Have Heard on High As with Gladness Men of Old Away in a Manger Beside the Manger Bethlehem, of Noblest Cities Break Forth, O Beauteous Heavenly Light Earth Has Many a Noble City Joy to the World Lo How a Rose E'er Blooming O Come All Ye Faithful Of the Father's Love Begotten Once in Royal David's City See Amid the Winter's Snow Silent Night Sleep, Holy Babe Virgin-Born, We Kneel Before Thee
Advent: Come, Thou Long Expected Jesus Creator of the Stars of Night Like the Dawning of the Morning [Christmas also] O Come, Divine Messiah The God Whom Earth and Sea and Sky [Christmas also]
ADVENT Come Thou Long-Expected Creator of the Starry Night Hark! A Herald Voice is Calling Like the Dawning of the Morning Lift Up Your Heads, Ye Mighty Gates (versatile) On Jordan's Bank (versatile) Saviour of the Nations, Come (Luther) Wake, Awake for Night is Flying
CHRISTMAS Angels From the Realms of Glory Angels We Have Heard Away in a Manger Beside the Manger Bethlehem, Of Noblest Cities Good Christians All, Rejoice (is this a typo?) Good Christian Men, Rejoice and Sing Joy to the World Lo! How a Rose O Come, All Ye Faithful Of the Father's Love Begotten Once in Royal David's City Silent Night Sleep, Holy Babe Virgin-Born, We Kneel Before Thee
VERSATILE Let All Mortal Flesh Keep Silence
SECOND ADVENT (partial list) Love Divine, All Loves Excelling Lo, He Comes
I'm kinda weirded out that there aren't more Advent songs. I did a whole homebrew album of Advent songs for my family Christmas present last year. (Went over like a ton of bricks, mind you, but the songs are out there.)
Other English Advent hymns on my list (not in PBEH):
The King Shall Come When Morning Dawns (early Advent) The Angel Gabriel from Heaven Came O Come, O Come Emmanuel Comfort, Comfort O My People People Look East The Advent of Our King The Coming of Our God
Sussex Carol
The Snow lay on the ground venite adoremus
O little town of Bethlehem (Forest Green)
While shepherds watched their flocks by night
My personal fav- Song of the Nuns of Chester ( the Oxford book of Carols)
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.