Speaking/singing and solemnity
  • Singing the mass adds solemnity, but I notice a reverse effect where occasional spoken parts in an otherwise sung mass have their own distinct solemnity. For example the "Ecce Agnus Dei" (either form) or the Penitential Act (NO or TLM if you do the second Confiteor). Kind of a shower thought, but I'm always interested when something seems to reverse a general rule.
    Thanked by 1Lars
  • SponsaChristi
    Posts: 900
    TLM if you do the second Confiteor)

    Unless it’s a solemn Mass. Then the second confiteor is sung by the subdeacon.

    The thing I don’t get is why in Masses that aren’t sung, does the priest/bishop decide to sing “through him, with him, and in him,[…]”? Why just that part? I often wonder why we don’t have fully sung solemn Masses anymore? And by fully sung, I mean fully sung.
  • LarsLars
    Posts: 149
    quote:
    "sing “through him,....... "

    I thought it was just in my neck of the woods, yes very strange, I had the most anti-singing priests chant this one line, no problem. so odd.
  • SponsaChristi
    Posts: 900

    I thought it was just in my neck of the woods, yes very strange, I had the most anti-singing priests chant this one line, no problem. so odd.

    I know, right? I could understand if one’s ability to sing literally sounds like a dying animal, but it has yet to be so.
    Thanked by 1Lars
  • And by fully sung, I mean fully sung.

    Readings too?
  • In the missal, the ordo conveniently provides music for some parts of the mass but not others. I can't confirm, but it could be that the missal just presents the Doxology as something that ought to be sung. I realize that would just push the question up a level into the great mystery of why the missal presents some things this way but not others.

    Some priests are also a little fixated on the ensuing "Great Amen" as a "highlight" of the liturgy.

    I think it comes down to instruction (there has been a complete failure to hand down the idea that the mass ought to be sung on more solemn occasions, not to mention teaching the singing skills themselves) and the fact that it requires more effort (anathema, of course).
  • In other news, my parish will soon begin singing the entire mass (well, except the 1st/2nd readings) for the Saturday vigil and Sunday 10am NO celebrations.

    I created a spreadsheet of the weekly masses showing every part I believe ought to be sung or spoken at each mass/each degree of solemnity. The priests were open to it. I even caved in advance on a few parts of the vigil mass, expecting pushback, but one of them actually said it should be done the same way as the Sunday mass.
  • a_f_hawkins
    Posts: 3,709
    Singing the doxology of the Canon is common in England. All dioceses teach their seminarians to do it. Since the 1965 missal required it to be spoken aloud, SRC/.../ DDW(DS) has regarded this and the AMEN as the focus of the Mass, insofar as there is a single moment when the priest offers the Sacrifice this gesture of offering is that moment.
    This should not detract from recognising that the elements must be Consecrated before they are offered.
  • SponsaChristi
    Posts: 900
    Readings too?

    Especially the readings.

    I struggle to understand what people are saying at Mass unless it’s sung. Or people practically eat the microphone and it’s loud, distorted, has too much reverb, and you can hear all the amplified mouth noises, which is gross and irritating.
  • That's a hard row to hoe. Does anyone have experience or a story about making sung readings happen?
  • LarsLars
    Posts: 149
    we sang ICEL mass, the priest asked me where is the Gloria from, I replied its from the missal, he could not believe it, he said if only he was taught this and many more chants in the seminary. ... it's sad.