The EWTN schedule indicates "EWTN Live" has television (or internet feed) encores http://www.ewtn.com/tv/NA_071909.asp Thu Jul 23 6 am USA Pacific ... 9 am USA Eastern
Ok, it's over. Good talk, but I was waiting to hear the schola singing a Gregorian chant, at least just one. (sigh) Fr. Martin was great. (and a great chanter too) He sounded like he knew what we were talking about here. How Gregorian chant singing is different from Protestant-style hymn singing. How the chants are perfect for the prayers, one just participates in that prayer and rest, so even if one doens't understand evey word, he can still be in the spirit of praising God, just like singing Alleuia, where oftentimes the music goes on after you completes singing the words, praising God beyond words.(although it is also good to understand the words, more important is being in that spirit of praising Him.Many Catholics don't know what 'Alleuia' means, but they still sing and praise God.), and how simple to read chant notes etc. There were challenging questions. I think he answered very well in such a short time.
(One interesting thing I learned, the Father who interviewd him was a Jesuit, and he says Jesuits don't spend time in chanting, because their mission is go out and do Apostolic work. Very interesting. I somehow thought they liked singing.)
I wish I can get a copy of this talk.
I caught the tail end of tonight's show, as my wife often flips the channels and likes to check EWTN. I just stumbled on this website after hearing about MusicaSacra while at the NPM convention in Chicago a couple of weeks ago. There were a couple of breakout sessions on chant and liturgical change. Chant is going to be the coming thing with the upcoming change in the liturgy and mass settings, so it will have an increasing audience in the coming years. This is going to be good job security for church music directors and musicians. Maybe I will be able to get myself a job somewhere when I retire (soon, hopefully)...
I would have loved to attend the Sacred Music Colloquim in Chicago last month but was unaware. Where/when is something approaching that next scheduled?
Northrup, I'm glad you got to see some part of the show. The Colloquium info is in the front page of this site, second tap from the left on the top. I attended the Colloquium this year (it was first time for me. I did Chant Intensive in Chicago, which usually is held one week before the Colloquium, last year though.) It was amazing and so beautiful. There are lots of thread in this forum talked about the Colloquium and recordings. I hope I see you there next year.
Welcome, Northrup; you might consider the event in DC announced on the home page of musicasacra.com. The date and location for next year's Colloquium haven't been announced yet, but that will come out in due course; you can expect it to be in late June.
I thought the show was overall very good - and I always like Fr. Mitch when I run across him. The level of the conversation and the answers to the questions were pitched at folks who don't know much about music. His great opener was that most Catholics were already singing at least tidbits of chant in the dialogues at Mass and they didn't even know it! (A useful line for folks who tell you chant is completely absent from the modern liturgy.)
It was particularly encouraging to me that Fr. Joel urged people to sing chant on their own, even if it were only with a recording, whatever the state of music in their own parish. Also interesting were his comments to the questioner who said he couldn't understand the words. Fr. Joel pointed out that he (Fr. Joel) often couldn't understand words in an English or Latin chant he was hearing, but that he still knew God was being praised. This caused me to reflect on how often we think the quality of worship depends on our comprehension of it. Hmmm.
And he did point out that while there were a few people who could never sing tunefully, over time most people can sing basic chant.
I just saw the replay this morning, since I had missed it last night. It has seemed to me for some time, that there is a difference between singing, as we know it, and chanting. I find many people who will never be singers, can chant.
It may be something about how chant is "processed" by the brain. I mean, most kids sing offkey when they're little, but they usually get all the notes right in nursery rhymes (which in a way are chanted). It might be an extension of how people are usually able to produce the proper tones of voice while speaking, even if they can't hit a note while singing. Hmm. Nice neuro topic for research, because in other ways chant is not much like speech -- it's not "speak-singing" at all, like much modern song is designed to be.
The audio is part of the EWTN archives. I provide these instructions, rather than a link, so that future readers of this Forum Discussion can access the program even after an archive reorganization.
http://www.ewtn.com (in banner menu line) Libraries -> Audio Library (scroll down to SECOND search box titled) Select from a list of EWTN Programs (in search box) Joel Martin (click button) Submit
(you should see the following)
Program Name: The Revival of Gregorian Chant [icon] Listen Now [icon] Download Series Name: EWTN Live Host: Fr. Mitch Pacwa, S.J. with Fr. Joel Martin, O.S.B. - Monastic Choir Director, St. Bernard Abbey Date Produced: 7/22/2009 Description: Fr. Martin shares with us the greatness and humility of the Chant and its relevance in today's Church and world
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.