In our diocese we have various safety guides in general as well as directives that state only a cantor and accompanist may be used at mass. I think the music during the liturgy is going well- congregant singing is wonderful, actually- but I have been asked to look at providing some sort of music before mass (piano or organ solos only to be in compliance with diocesan directives). Liturgical norms favor silence, and I tend to question whether my playing provides more benefit than silence for those to listen to God, so I did not play instrumental preludes regularly pre-COVID. My pastor- and actually congregants- have asked from some preludes to be done regularly during this time that would provide comfort, peace, and beauty. Before I dive into the online music stores, are there any particularly beautiful and effective you could recommend? I am looking for sheet music because I do not improvise (darn it). A recommended book would be even better. I am advanced piano but probably only intermediate organ. Open to and looking for music for both instruments.
At my parish during June at a request by me, our music director played some old hymn tunes to the Sacred Heart, no singing, as prelude. There are many devotional hymns that could be used in this manner. A couple of weeks ago she did Jesus My Lord, My God, My All.
The function of the prelude is to set the tone of the day's celebration. If it is a joyful day or one that celebrates God's grandeur, Christ's kingship or lordship, etc., the prelude should reflect this and not be soft and maudlin. A Bach prelude, a Couperin plein jeu and basse de trompette, Langlais' Te Deum, etc., would prepare the people for the joyful nature of that day. Let the organ rejoice!
On other occasions the prelude might be more subdued but not anything like soft 'background' music. There are many German choral preludes or French recits, etc., that would set the tone for such a day.
Too, one should not overlook movements from Tournemire's L'orgue mystique, written for specific days of the liturgical kalendar. Each of its movements is based on a plainchant cantus firmus drawn from the day's propers.
Whatever the day or season the prelude should most definitely not be soft, innocuous, background music. Such music is really not 'prayerful' - it is an insult from someone who has no imagination. It should always be real music of the highest calibre that relates to the day's theme and mood.
And! There should be no announcements between the prelude and the processional hymn. One should modulate into the hymn and begin singing it immediately. There should always be an inviolable and uninterrupted flow from one part of the liturgy to the next, and this applies to the ornamental prelude (and postlude).
Please don't play piano preludes. I came to organ from being already an advanced pianist, and there is no shortage of real organ repertoire that is manageable. And at some point I looked back and said, "hey, look at that. I've been playing organ for 10 years, and my feet are actually not doing too bad anymore, e.g. they are part of my sight-reading apparatus just like my hands, even if I'm not an absolute whiz."
*****
Available on IMSLP, some collections of pieces which I have played either many selections from or in their entirety:
Pachelbel - Magnificat fugues Titelouze - Versets DuMage - Suite du premiere ton (his only surviving work) Couperin - Messe pour les Couvents / pour les Paroisses Dandrieu - Offertoires Clerambault - Suites Daquin - Noels (Daquin is the king of Noels!) Lebegue - Noels, Offertoires Frescobaldi - Ricercars
*****
A technique I have used is to take something like a suite, and play the entire thing, either one movement each week, or else multiple movements each week if I wanted to present a more lengthy offering. I have also done that with sets of pieces, for example taken eight weeks and played the eight Little Preludes and Fugues of Bach. There are two advantages to such an approach: one is that you are forced to come to terms with the pieces of the set that have less immediate appeal, and the other is that when you are done you have added a much more substantial block to your list of played repertoire.
[A side note: I did a blog post HERE describing how I played Couperin's Messe pour les Paroisses over the course of seven postludes. Another anecdote, once for a wedding I did, I could truthfully say that the organ music consisted of "The complete works of Pierre DuMage".]
I would like to point out that the French Baroque concept of the organ is surprisingly unlike that of Bach. The use of the pedals in many cases falls into one of the following two categories: either 1) to take the cantus firmus in the tenor on say a 8' trumpet stop; or 2) to take the bass voice in a trio with a soft 8' flute. Neither of these is anything like the involvement of the pedals in a Bach fugue. And if you have a suite with eight movements, pedals as like as not will only feature in two, i.e. one of each.
[Edit - I feel the need to put in a note as to what I have not played: Most of the Pachelbel I haven't played. Certainly not all of the Titelouze. And I never got to the Messe pour les Couvents, because I couldn't come up with an appropriate chant Mass to pair it with.]
In my experience having to use an instrument without a pedalboard, Bach's works are about the latest that will work on both instruments. Sweelinck, Pachelbel, and some Buxtehude are among the works equally suited for stringed keyboard instruments and organ, and might be more approachable depending on your technique.
@francis, anthologies such as you have linked are one way of approaching repertoire, but I was also trying to "put in a advertisement" for the notion of drinking deeper draughts of the stuff, taking sometimes whole cycles of pieces rather than always excerpts. I think I stumbled on this idea when I was starting to feel like I had played all of the usable pieces in the collections that I had on hand in hard copy. It hit me - if this is a pretty good noel by Daquin, maybe there are other Noels out there? Etc. And in that particular case, it turned out when I played the rest of Daquin's noels that there are a good handful that I like better than the original one I knew from E. Power Biggs "Treasury of Early Organ Music". I have found a lot of music that way.
(Anthologies have the advantage of broadening your outlook. And also bringing into easy view the accessible pieces so that you don't have to go hunting for them. I'm not really out to shoot down anthologies, I just don't think that they are the be all end all.)
Playing complete cycles of pieces was also preferable to me because once I had decided how to program something, it would cover several weeks in a nice, satisfying trajectory. Just curious - has anyone else tried this?
The thing to avoid was that a series of one-off's when I had run out of ideas could start to feel schizophrenic, or like I was scrabbling to keep up.
Though, who knows how the congregation perceived either, if at all.
I have played through the Pachelbel Magnificat fugues in a cycle like you mentioned. Having a such a large set of pieces takes a lot of pressure off continuously searching for more instrumental music week after week. Plus, they're easy. I'm going to look into the Scheidemann Magnificat fugues next.
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.