This is an ideal publication for parishes which tried the Lalemant Propers and/or the Recto Tono Hymnal and found them too difficult.
It should be noted that the 'propers' that the priest speaks, mumbles, or whispers, are not The Propers. ....
Jackson - do you mean that to apply to Divine Worship: the Missal, for which the texts appear to me to be the same. or just to the Roman Missal? I realise of course that DWtM does not give the plethora of new selections found in the ferial two year cycle.The 'antiphons' which appear in the missal are not The Propers.
The entrance and communion antiphons of the Missal were intended to be recited, not sung, and to inspire the creation of suitable songs in the vernacular.
....are not sung by a choir or cantor at a given mass, then there are no Propers at that particular mass.
What Chonak describes is, after all, precisely what is supposed to happen if there are not any GR Propers or other sung music. When there are no propers or other music, then the 'antiphons' in the missal are what are to be said by the priest - not sung by the priest or anyone else.
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.