I am still looking for de Victoria for addition to this list. Over several years have heard about his cause for canonization, from two widely different sources, but can't find anything about it on my own yet.
The fact that Fulton Sheen was an organist blew my mind. I'm playing through the scenario in my mind of an episode of Life is Worth Living where he plays "dueling organs" with his special guest star: "Bish vs. (Arch)Bish".
on a list of "musicians, singers, and composers", I was surprised to see Pope St. Gregory the Great, notated "collected melodies and plain chant". I wonder, did he play, sing, or compose?
Gregory did, or had done by others, some re-ordering and codifying of the chant repertory, but it isn't likely that he actually composed any chant. There are some hymns that are attributed to him - which means texts, not melodies.
His largely imaginary wholesale responsibility for the chant repertory which he inherited and to some degree revised, and to which posterity attached his name, was in no small part responsible for the worshipful esteem which the Roman chant came to be held throughout Romanitas lands and its spread throughout Charlemagne's empire - heavily 'influenced' by the chant of Frankish scholars.
I understood the term "composer" would be a bit controversial. "Lyricists" might have been a better term for some, while others used popular or existing tunes (or chant odes) of their own time with their text. In a loose sense of the word, the "composers" did "compose" songs...they just didn't have the gift of a tune or the ability to write one. No doubt they appreciated, in an anticipatory sense, the music that would indeed be sung for their texts. We have to remember the very long historical traditions that the Church has passed through in regards to music and not impose our 21st century concept onto 1st or 10th century affairs.
What about St. Alphonse de Liguori? He wrote the popular Christmas hymn "Tu scendi dalle stelle," which I will warn you is a major earworm, so listen with caution.
I would add my mentor, Anglican, Peter R. Hallock (1924-2014) to the list. A prolific composer, conductor, organist, counter tenor; he personally brought back the ancient office of Compline to a world wide audience. He was a real talent, a Renaissance man with a broad and deep legacy. Another is Richard Proulx (1937-2010). What a dedicated Roman, organist, conductor, composer, with a rich musical print legacy. Both of these men are what i call, "in the category of the mystical". These are the only two in my lifetime in this category. Am I correct is assuming the subject musician must be in the deceased category?
>> Could we stop using the "musicians and singers" terminology? It's like saying "apples and Granny Smiths".
hm. I know someone who can compose, arrange, and play piano and organ beautifully, but cain't sing a lick. And someone else who will sing - beautifully - till you get tired and run them off, but they can't even play 'chopsticks'.
People who write, perform, or direct music are musicians. Whether or not they are any good at these things is another matter entirely, and a job for other words.
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.