Is there any rubrical justification that would allow the following practices?
(a) At the end of a (spoken) reading, for someone other than the lector to sing "The Word of the Lord"?
(b) For someone other than the person reading the intentions for the Prayer of the Faithful to sing "Let us pray to the Lord/Be pleased to hear us/etc." ? (I know this is commonly done for Masses in Rome at which the Holy Father presides, but I'm wondering if there is some text to back it up)
I acknowledge its 'bizzare' nature - however, the point is to attempt to get people used to the idea of the readings as sung - the (sensible) suggestion was made to start with the dialogues, in the same way as the Gospel dialogues are often sung but the text read.
However, many of the readers object that they can not sing the conclusion (simple as it is.....there is no convincing some people) and that will probably sway the the Powers-that-Be who are not terribly familiar or enthusiastic about the increased singing. If, on the other hand, a member of the choir could "fill-in" for the sung bits, that would remove one big set of objections....the hope would be that eventually people would get so used to the tune that the readers would end up doing it themselves.
Thank you johnmann...... I looked in the GIRM (which seemed to say "no"), the Ordo Cantus Missae and even the Graduale- but for some reason, it didn't occur to me to look in the most obvious place!
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.