I wasn't aware there was any irony or even merely camp sensibility: rather, a viral prank that also provides a pretext for malicious abuse by the sociopathically inclined (as, if memory serves, has also happened with viral pranks in the past).
(None of the above are clowns per se, but some are clown dolls. Then again, it was that Zuni doll menacing Karen Black that was perhaps the most unnerving because it came of left field. I remember seeing that in its original airing, and it was indelible. Ah, the mid-1970s - an era of dark imagination. The Exorcist is scary because, while it has its prurient moments, it retains a powerful tether to supernatural realities: the scariest line in the screenplay is when Ellen Burstyn bursts out, "You show me Regan's double: same face, same voice, same everything. I'd know it wasn't Regan. I'd know in my gut and I'm telling you that that thing upstairs isn't my daughter!"")
Arguably, the Joker in Batman is another menacing clown, who became more menacing with the darker movie renditions of more recent years.
Ultimately my problem with tattoos is that God, in Nature is an infinitely better artist than the best of all human artists. Drawing on his masterpiece is like giving a toddler a crayon and telling them to draw something on the Mona Lisa.
Clowns have always been on the edge between funny and being sinister. I have found that many children, who are supposed to be entertained by clowns, actually fear them. This sort of thing tends to show up before Halloween each year.
Clown makeup functions as a mask. When masked people appear in public (and not in the regulated environment of a performance), people naturally suspect that they are hiding their faces for a nefarious reason.
The clown thing also deals with darkness, I believe. The idea of a crazed person at night dressed as a clown is very scary. Some guy walking around dressed as a clown during the day? Not so scary.
Tattoos were somewhat rare in the U.S. when I was growing up. I remember my mother telling me they were trashy and low class, which was the prevailing view in her time. The only people who had them were people who had been in the navy. There was some naval rite of passage connected with them, apparently. They have been popularized by rock stars and heavy metal groups among the young. Some of that music is pretty dark, so whether any of it is, as some say, satanic, is anyone's guess. I neither have nor want one.
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.