Hymn Book Comparison

noel jones, aago

I had though Ben >•< had done one of these, but I was (as often is the case) wrong,

Needed.

Adam Wood

What are you imagining?

noel jones, aago

Simple list.

Liturgy, number of Mass settings, hymns, prayers Availability of Accompaniment book. Hard or Soft Bound. Price. Link.

Though it would be immense use if annual/quarterly produced books were listed for comparison.

If there is something out there already, it'd be nice to see it, Adam <•>.

Adam Wood

That sounds super useful.
GIA (I think!) has an index of indexes for their family of hymnals, but that would be of limited use 'round these parts.

I feel like I've seen something like what you're describing, but I could be imagining it.

-Adam



 
 ==\ /==
   | |
   | | 
   | |
   | |
   \ /

chonak

Adam, what's that supposed to be?

Adam Wood

Adam, what's that supposed to be?

Took some trial and error for alignment.
I hope it is now clear that it is a REAL NECK TIE.

irishtenor

Better than a CROOKED BOWTIE!!

canadash

Is this what you had thought of: http://forum.musicasacra.com/forum/discussion/12790/hymn-book-comparison#Item_7

chonak

I think Adam is laboring under a mistaken antecedent.

Adam Wood

I've re-read this thread a half-dozen times and am still confused.
Were you not asking about the bad ASCII art?

noel jones, aago

I thought it was some sort of anti-vaccine statement...

noel jones, aago

I think Canadash was linking to this:

http://forum.musicasacra.com/forum/discussion/6440/comparison-of-hymnals-st.-michael-vatican-ii-worship-iv-adoremus-etc./p1

canadash

ooopsss...

Welcome to the MusicaSacra Forum!

Categories