A couple events happened at the OHS convention in Syracuse, which I thought might be of interest to you. On Monday, Aug 11, the opening recital was by Hector Olivera. The organ was a Aeolian/Holtkamp three manual. Response from the audience was modest at first but Hector, with his personality, won over the people and the response became very enthusiastic. He acknowledged that he often performs on electronic instruments. He was musical as usual. The OHS is no longer all tracker backers.
Second, Friday, Aug 15 was an optional day at the end of the convention. There was a 4:00 pm closing recital at St. Mary of the Assumption RC Church in Auburn. The church was organ was a two manual Carl Barckhoff organ from 1890. It was quite robust. There was also a one manual organ up front. The recital was well attended by parish members, which was a bit of a surprise. The recital by Jonathan Ryan was good and was received well.
Later, at 7:00 pm, about one bus full of us stayed for a patronal festival mass for the Assumption of the BVM, celebrated by the bishop of Rochester. I assume there's no guitars and drums at this church, which may seat about 600 by my guess. The evening mass, which was very well attended, had lots of fairly loud organ introductions and an opening and closing hymn in English, which the people sang well with strong leading by the rear organ and choir. Except for the homily in English, most of the rest of the mass was in Latin. The printed program had notation in chant format, which I'm not used to. It often alternated between one phrase sung by the schola and then a phrase sung by all. However, lots of people were singing the people's parts of the mass. Obviously the parish is used to the chanted Latin music. This mass was an eye opener for me, who is used to somewhat unenthusiastic singing and music at RC churches that I've visited from time to time.
It sort of shows how important having a pastor on board is, to actual success in Catholicising the music program at a Catholic parish.
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.