Yes, I know. Musicians should be paid. But for those volunteer musicians out there who play or direct on a weekly or very regular basis for whatever reason, do you consider that part of your tithe?
I'm not really talking about one-off Masses/events where you volunteer to do it as a help, I'm thinking of you who are volunteering every week or a couple times a month with little or no stipend due to the parish/group/community circumstances.
I would suggest that volunteers should bill out of their tithe. That is to say, if you put in 5 hours at the church, tithe 1/8 less, since 1/8 of your productive time is going to the Church.
Ultimately, it's a private decision and the individual person must make that call.
I donate a ton of time to the church, not just in the music ministry but with Knights of Columbus. I also give a small sum in the weekly collection and to other charities like immaculate heart radio, Catholic Charities and the like. Financially I do not give 10% of my Gross, but if you figure all the time and all the publications and learning materials that I purchase for my choir, out of pocket, I give way more than 10% of Gross, this does not include the time my wife puts in as accompanist. We do get paid for Weddings and Funerals.
I include whatever I am paid through any source (church, secular work, garage sale revenue) in "income" and we do 10% - 5% to our parish and 5% for "special projects" which might be anything from a specific charity or natural disaster cause to helping an out-of-work neighbor pay their rent.
Volunteer work does not absolve me any of the 10%. Otherwise, that would be paid work, which would increase the base for 10% at the same time that it is credits against it. And then I'd have to remember calculus or something.
Same situation at my church as CharlesW. We tithe both time/talent and income, but being a low income family there are many times when my "faith in fiddles" is all I have to give. For me, I consider anything a person has to offer part of their tithe, and I feel fortunate to be in a church community that supports this.
I agree. Whatever you can give is all God expects of you. I rarely mention this, but I give back 20 to 25% of what the parish pays me. Half goes to the parish and the other half goes to Catholic charitable organizations that help the poor. This is not a boast but gratitude that I am able to do this. I have been in the position in my younger days when I had more time than money to give. I suspect the Lord appreciated the offering of what I had. I think He still does whether it be money or time.
To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.