BGP

Yes
Yes
Slightly
No

Thanked by 1Liam
I have set the North American form of it to Plainchant. This is very much incomplete and in progress but feedback welcomed.

Edit- I wish they had included the antiphon for the psalms, …

Thanked by 4IanW M. Jackson Osborn veromary CHGiffen
I just discovered this.

https://archive.org/details/78_psalmody-1-elements-of-psalmody_dr-clifford-bennett-rev-joseph-kush-cgm_gbia8000602a

Thanked by 3CHGiffen MatthewRoth NihilNominis
My smarmy quote above has a point. We use artificial lights but replacing altar candles with them (should be) obviously undesirable, nothing is more tacky than artificial votive lights. I do not beli…

Thanked by 3irishtenor rich_enough Elmar
"The era of candles is over we need to transition to incandescent bulbs."

Thanked by 1Elmar
The Monastic Diurnal resources mentioned are of course of the monastic rather than Roman office and use the official Anglican translations. Douglas’s adaptations are pretty decent.

Th…

Thanked by 1igneus
chonak, yes I am aware of that but am being asked to use the Missal text in English I just threw something together and am posting it here for posterity and critique.

Thanked by 1Richard Mix
More or less as rarty describes. Pope Urban the 8th thought it was a great idea to have Jesuits alter a large number of the hymns, many penned by saints, because they weren't "as Cicero wou…

Thanked by 4CHGiffen CCooze Liam Incardination
Jonathan- that's pretty cool.

Thanked by 1JonathanKK
The 1908 Gradual used the same texts as the ancient Graduals. Prior to this it was required to sing the identical texts found in the Missal of Trent. This is Likely the cause of the discrepancy.

Thanked by 1 tomjaw
Not sure I follow Mr. Osborn.

Shakespeare for example. I think it highly important that High Schoolers read him. I think it less concerning that they fail to use historically correct p…

Thanked by 1dad29
I disagree. I have encountered a good number of cases in which people don't like chant, and in many of these cases, it seems that is in part due to the fact that what they hear is ........
…

Thanked by 2M. Jackson Osborn CharlesW
Seems to be an uptick in these type of discussions on here lately. These sort of details it seems to me are the least we should be concerned with when the average Catholic at the average parish is (g…

Thanked by 2Jenny CharlesW
"The verdict is in." would mean it is decisively and definitely proved for all time. These sort of details will be perpetually debatable (barring the discovery of a clear, unambiguous, yet …

Thanked by 1CCooze
Thank you M. Jackson Osborn.

Yes I think we could have an interesting conversation... I believe we have bumped noses on this subject on here in the past and I remember feeling somewha…

Thanked by 1M. Jackson Osborn
Kathy, are you trying to stir turds? ;-) My take-

Old Solesmes – by this I take it to mean the practical ideas of Dom Mocquereau including further and continual development by Gajard …

Thanked by 2bhcordova M. Jackson Osborn
What specifically are you looking for?

Absolution in Latin was very common until the post V2 conciliar absolution formula came about.

Dominus noster Jesus Christus te a…

Thanked by 3mmeladirectress CHGiffen Liam
Geremia,

I would recommend the book "Singing in God's Ear" by Dom Nicholson OSB.

Long out of print but you should be able to find it if you go looking. L…

Thanked by 5Chris Garton-Zavesky bhcordova Geremia Arthur Connick noel jones, aago
St. Johns Abbey Press, the copy I am looking at is 1951 with a 1942 imprimatur.
The status/legitimacy singing the English publicly at that time ... ... ..........................

Thanked by 2Ben igneus
It exists in a grey covered pamphlet from that era. Not sure who published it. I can look later.

Thanked by 1igneus
Not sure if this is allowed, moderators - go ahead and delete if it's not.

I have a number of liturgical books I want to get rid of. Before I put them on ebay I thought I'd m…

Thanked by 2moderntrad M. Jackson Osborn
Thank You Matthew. Excuse my ignorance. The "Dutch touch" of course refers to the presence of Dutch Old Catholic consecrators in ones ordination lineage. Was there a concerted effort in Eng…

Thanked by 1Elmar
The reason for bringing in the SSPX as a self supported structure seems obvious to me. It is a unit, breaking it up and placing the local chapels under local bishops is essentially a dissolving of th…

Thanked by 1CHGiffen
Well, the article I referred to is page 9 here http://media.musicasacra.com/publications/caecilia/caecilia_v82n01_1954_11.pdf
The author speaks as in a way opaque to me at least (I feel like …

Thanked by 1tomjaw
Yes, 'Repleatur' which Tomjaw and Hugh have both posted. I was introduced to it by the Franciscans of the Immaculate and have been trying to track down information on it's history or o…

Thanked by 1tomjaw
Teach them (and if neccesary learn yourself) chant notation and solfege.

And teach them (and yourself if neccesary) to not be afraid of it.

Thanked by 1GregoryWeber

Welcome to the MusicaSacra Forum!

To participate in the discussions on Catholic church music, sign in or register as a forum member, The forum is a project of the Church Music Association of America.

About

Username: BGP
Joined: July 2009
Visits: 265
Last Active: May 20
Roles: Member
Posts: 230
Thanked: 124