Sing A New Church (Sorry, my old church lol used to sing this too much)
All People that on Earth Do Dwell
Songs of Thankfulness and Praise
Come Thou Redeemer of the Earth
Now the Green Blade Riseth
Love Divine...
Glory Be to God the Father
God Created Earth and Heaven (Really...)
Sing with All the Saints in Glory
Hail the Day that Sees Him Rise
Fairest Lord Jesus
Let All Things now Living
Tantum Ergo (? Wade?)
The Advent of Our God
Silence! Frenzied, Unclean Spirit! (http://forum.musicasacra.com/forum/discussion/11409/combine-two-or-more-hymn-titles-to-create-something-new)
Come, Ye Thankful People, Come

My choices are from someone who has only been exposed to good sacred music for a short period of time...

Nettleton — God, We Praise You
Old Hundredth — All People That on Earth Do Dwell
Salzburg — At the Lamb’s High Feast We Sing
Puer Nobis — That Easter Day with Joy Was Bright
Noel Nouvelet — Now the Green Blade Rises
Hyfrydol — Love Divine, All Loves Excelling
Regent Square — Angels, from the Realms of Glory
Beach Spring — Lord, Whose Love in Humble Service
Ode to Joy — Joyful, Joyful We Adore Thee
Llanfair — Christ the Lord is Risen Today
St. Elizabeth — Beautiful Savior (Crusader’s Hymn)
Ash Grove — Let All Things Now Living
St. Thomas — Tantum Ergo
St. Thomas (Williams) — O Bless the Lord, My Soul
Ebenezer — [No association]
St. George's Windsor — Come, Ye Thankful People, Come

I would like to see a show of hands from everyone who could identify the tune WHITE LADIES ASTON. (I was not one of you!)

I enjoy the whimsical names given to hymn tunes, but this one is in it's own category. I would love to hear the story behind the name! It turns out to be quite a lovely little modal tune, which I am certain I have never run across.

High churchy indeed! Ha! Liam's (raucous) example is nothing at all like (saving for a very loose melodic resemblance and modality) the sedate text and mode iii version that I stumbled across in the 1906 edition of The English Hymnal. By Ivor Atkins, it may be found at no. 400 therein, set to this text by W. Cowper:
'Hark, may soul! It is the Lord;
'Tis thy Saviour, hear his word;
Jesus speaks, and speaks to thee:
"Say, poor sinner, lov'st thou me?"'

Sung at just the right tempo it could be rather meditative and reverent.
There are numerous other 7.7.7.7. texts that are more worthy by far.

I know White Ladies Aston, and I have actually been there, it's in Worcestershire, and has a good team of morris dancers, I believe. The village got its name from a mediaeval Cistercian nunnery nearby. There are quite a number of Anglican hymns named after English villages, eg Down Ampney, King's Weston etc

Hymn tunes:

Nettleton Sing of Andrew, John's disciple (this is in Scotland)
Old Hundredth All people that on earth do dwell
Salzburg At the Lamb's high feast we sing
also Little king so fair and sweet (learned at primary school)
Puer Nobis Unto us a boy is born (but I think this is a different tune)
Puer nobis (another tune) Come thou redeemer of the earth
Noel Nouvelet Now the green blade riseth
Hyfrydol Alleluia, sing to Jesus
Regent Square Lord, enthroned in heavenly splendour
Beach Spring God of day and God of darkness
Ode to Joy Sing of Christ proclaim His glory (and yes, we do the correct rhythm)
Llanfair Hail the day that sees Him rise
St. Elizabeth Fairest Lord Jesus
Ash Grove The folk song of that name. Don't know of a hymn set to it. I believe there was a hideous thing called The Ash Grove Gloria, set to that tune, One of those things where the creator saw fit to adapt the text from the Missal to fit the tune. Now banned, thankfully.
St. Thomas Pange lingua, or Sing my tongue, the glorious battle Tune is by Samuel Webbe the elder
St. Thomas (Williams) ?
Ebenezer O the deep deep love of Jesus (beautiful Welsh tune)
St. George's Windsor Come ye thankful people, come

and the next lot:
This endris nyght This endris night I saw a sight
Blaenwern Love Divine
Winchester Old While Shepherds watched (This has many tunes including a wonderful Yorkshire one called On Ilkley Moor bah't 'at
Wareham The glory of the cross we sing
Merton Hark, a herald voice is calling
St Albinus Jesus lives! thy terrors now
St MagnusThe head that once was crowned with thorns (big celebrations in Orkney this summer to mark the 900th anniversary of the martyrdom of St Magnus)
Third Mode Melody I heard the voice of Jesus say
Tallis' Canon (other than 'All praise to thee, my God, this night') Almighty Father, Lord most high
White Ladies Aston Hark my soul, it is the Lord
Duke Street (how many) Here it is reserved for Fight the Good Fight
Regent Square (not 'Angels from the realms...') see above
Darwall's 148th Reoice, the Lord is king
Gonfalon Royal The royal banners forward go
St Fulbert The race that once in darkness pined

Nettleton = n/a
Old Hundredth = All people that on earth do dwell (I also use this for Kathy's Introits)
Salzburg = At the Lamb's high feast
Puer Nobis = Come thou redeemer
Noel Nouvelet = Noel Nouvelet (oddly enough)
Hyfrydol = Alleluia, sing to Jesus
Regent Square = Angels from the realms of glory
Beach Spring = n/a
Ode to Joy = Freude, schone Gotterfunken, tochter aus Elysium
Llanfair = Christ the Lord is ris'n today
St. Elizabeth = n/a
Ash Grove = Let all things now living
St. Thomas = Tantum Ergo
St. Thomas (Williams) = n/a
Ebenezer = n/a
St. George's Windsor = Hail Redeemer, King divine
---
This endris nyght = Thys ender nyght
Blaenwern = n/a
Winchester Old = While shepherds watched
Wareham = (I use this as a tune for Kathy's metrical Introits, so there are too many texts to name
Merton = n/a
St Albinus = n/a
St Magnus = Ye choirs of new Jerusalem
Third Mode Melody = Why fum'th in sight the gentile's spite
Tallis' Canon = O thou immortal holy light
White Ladies Aston = n/a
Duke Street (how many) = Jesus shall reign; I know that my redeemer lives; also Kathy's Introit Hymns
Regent Square (not 'Angels from the realms...') = n/a
Darwall's 148th = Ye holy angels bright
Gonfalon Royal = n/a
St Fulbert = n/a

Nettleton - God We Praise You
Old Hundredth - All Hail Adored Trinity
Salzburg - At the Lamb's High Feast
Puer Nobis - What Star Is This/That Easter Day
Noel Nouvelet - Now the Green Blade Riseth
Hyfrydol - Alleluia, Sing to Jesus/Love Divine, All Loves Excelling
Regent Square - Angels from the Realms of Glory
Beach Spring - None
Ode to Joy - Joyful, Joyful, We Adore Thee
Llanfair - Christ the Lord Is Risen Today/Hail the Day that Sees Him Rise
St. Elizabeth - Beautiful Savior
Ash Grove - Sent Forth by God's Blessing
St. Thomas - Tantum Ergo
St. Thomas (Williams) - The Advent of Our King
Ebenezer - None
St. George's Windsor - Come Ye Thankful People, Come

Nettleton - God, we praise you; however, until a few years ago when we moved to singing mainly propers, I would have said Blessed feasts of blessed martyrs which we used often as an entrance hymn
Old Hundredth - All hail, adored Trinity (3 verses, with Praise God from Whom all blessings flow appended as a 4th verse)
Salzburg - Songs of thankfulness and praise
Puer Nobis - That Easter day with joy was bright
Noel Nouvelet - none (I associate Green Blade with another tune)
Hyfrydol - Alleluia! Sing to Jesus and (equally) Love divine, all loves excelling
Regent Square - Angels from the realms of glory
Beach Spring - Portal of the world's salvation (for the Visitation, or a Saturday memorial of the BVM)
Ode to Joy - Sing with all the sons of glory
Llanfair - Hail the day that sees him rise
St. Elizabeth - none
Ash Grove - Let all things now living
St. Thomas - Tantum ergo
St. Thomas (Williams) - none
Ebenezer - none
St. George's Windsor - Come, ye thankful people, come


This endris nyght - none
Blaenwern - none
Winchester Old - none
Wareham - none
Merton - Hark! A thrilling voice is calling
St Albinus - none
St Magnus - none
Third Mode Melody - none
Tallis' Canon - none
White Ladies Aston - none
Duke Street (how many) - only Jesus shall reign where e'er the sun
Regent Square (not 'Angels from the realms...') - only Angels
Darwall's 148th - Rejoice, the Lord is king
Gonfalon Royal - Sing to the Lord a joyful song
St Fulbert - none

As far as rhythms, we sing them as printed in our hymnals, correctly as printed; I can't speak for the correctness of the editors who printed the hymnals.

Gwalchmai King of glory, king of peace
St Stephen (is this the one also known as Abridge?) We don't use it, but our local Church Of Scotland, where I sometimes play the organ, uses it to Praise waits for thee in Zion
The First Nowell er,,,,the First Nowell
Redhead No. 47 Christ is king of earth and heaven
Gevaert ? have a feeling it's a Christmas carol of some sort
Lux Eoi This tune by Sir Arthur Sullivan is sung by the Church of England to Alleluia, alleluia, Hearts to heaven and voices raise
In Babilone There's a wideness in God's mercy
Bryn Calfaria ?
Rockingham When I survey the wondrous cross Samuel Webbe the Younger wrote an intersting harmony to this tune
Dulce Carmen Tantum ergo
Cobb ?
Dix As with gladness men of old
Ratisbon ?
Ab Hyd Y Nos Should be Ar Hyd Y Nos Day is done but love unending (also Welsh folk song All through the night)
St Clement The day thou gavest, Lord, is ended
Mendon ?
St Matthew Another C of S one The earth belongs to God alone
Newman ?
Cranham In the bleak midwinter
Redhead No. 46 ?
Redhead No. 76 also known as Petra.. Rock of ages

Nettleton - Hymns I don't really like all that much
Old Hundredth - Come to His Aid, O Saints of God
Salzburg - At the Lamb's High Feast
Puer Nobis - Puer Nobis
Noel Nouvelet - Now the Green Blade Riseth
Hyfrydol - Alleluia, Sing to Jesus
Regent Square - Angels from the Realms
Beach Spring - Love Divine, All Loves Excelling
Ode to Joy - Freude, Schoene Gotterfunken Tochter aus Elysium
Llanfair - N/A
St. Elizabeth - Beautiful Saviour
Ash Grove - Sent Forth by God's Blessing
St. Thomas - Nothing if I can help it
St. Thomas (Williams) - O Bless the Lord, My Soul
Ebenezer - N/A
St. George's Windsor - Come, Ye Thankful People

...how many here bury alleluia for Lent

The kids at my present church make a large 'Alleluia' banner each year after Epiphany, and then, after service on the last Sunday after Epiphany, hide it somewhere in the church until Easter morning, when they get to pull it out again and hang it at the back of the Nave. No 'Alleluia's' during Lent here!

Gwalchmai - none
St Stephen - none
The First Nowell - ahh... The First Noel
Redhead No. 47 - Youtube is only suggesting No 76 to me.
Gevaert - Youtube not showing me the tune, so I don't know
Lux Eoi - none
In Babilone - There's a Wideness in God's Mercy
Bryn Calfaria - none
Rockingham - When I Survey the Wondrous Cross
Dulce Carmen - none
Cobb - Youtube not showing me the tune, so I don't know
Dix - for the Beauty of the Earth
Ratisbon - none
Ab Hyd Y Nos - Day is Done but Love Unfailing
St Clement - it's almost the tune that was used for an Australian folk setting of The Lord is my Shepherd (Boniwell)- but not quite.
Mendon - none
St Matthew none
Newman - Praise to the Holiest in the Height
Cranham - In the Bleak Midwinter
Redhead No. 46 - none
Redhead No. 76 - none