Learning how to conduct chant properly when you already direct a choir
  • Any tips on how a beginner should go about learning to conduct chant? (Other than attending Colloquium, unfortunately, as circumstances don't allow for this)
  • Better than Colloquium for learning how to direct chant would be Fr Columba's summer workshops at St Meinrad's Archabbey. (This is not, otherwise, intended as a denigrance of Colloquium.)
    Thanked by 1canadash
  • Our summer Chant Intensive courses (next summer will feature Jenny Donelson teaching) are also great for that... also Fr. Mark Bachmann will begin working with people on the Solesmes method kicking off a first class (in English) next summer, to be followed up with correspondence work. Both courses will be at Duquesne University next summer.

    I know you mentioned you cannot attend the Colloquium this year, but if you could, we have a new chant choir that will focus on chant conducting -- this year it will be led by Scott Turkington... (just sayin').

    Last idea... if you cannot go somewhere to get the training, maybe you can sponsor a workshop and bring in a fine chant conductor to your area. Perhaps if you allow a little time in the schedule, the guest conductor would give you and others who are interested some personalized instruction.
    Thanked by 1canadash
  • CCoozeCCooze
    Posts: 1,259
    A beginning chant-er directing chant, or a beginning director, already solid in chant?

    If the latter, I'd say sing (chant) through something that you are completely confident in your performance of, and then start conducting yourself. Figure out what your gestures actually mean to yourself, and whether or not it would as obviously mean the same thing to someone else - even if you were conducting choral music, rather than chant.
    Thanked by 2canadash CHGiffen
  • What I learned myself is basically traditional Solesmes method, and without a lot of workshops.

    Solfege I got from majoring in music. A resource I would refer to is the FSSP's page; basically, however you go about it, you want to have the skill of being able to sight-sing, and conversely, to hear things and be able to write them down / identify them. That way, you are not tied to an instrument or recording, but can learn any new chant straight out of the book. Singing exercises, simple melodies, intervals, scales on solfege is the sort of thing to do; also taking dictation, as it were.

    How to do Solesmes counting and place the ictus is the sort of thing you can read in any number of places; I usually direct people to the summary in the back of the Parish Book of Chant for a concise explanation of these rules. At first, it is a good exercise to mark up a copy of a chant so that all the counting is figured out. Also to sing the counting. Eventually, you want to be able to sight-sing while also observing the correct counting, on the fly.

    How to do Solemes arsis / thesis conducting I learned about from The Technique of Gregorian Chironomy. Basically, one of the main points of worrying about the ictus is so that you have a framework on which to hang your conducting gestures. Each ictus can either be conducted as a sort of rising, or falling. A problem that I remember having when I read this book was that I could not understand from the diagrams how the gestures ought to be made. I think I finally saw this simple video, which rather cleared things up. [Or as another example, here is a random video I came across recently which has some clear shots of Solesmes conducting.] I should mention, when you are working on this arsis / thesis stuff, you mark up your scores with those peculiar wave-lines (or else A's and T's) to show the results of your analysis of how a particular chant should be conducted; and you eventually learn to do this more on the fly.

    So, that is partially how I mostly self-taught myself chironomy.

    This summer, I attended the CMAA's Summer Chant Intensive for Directors, which was useful. The interesting thing was to see how Mr. Brouwers would use Solesmes arsis / thesis conducting as a foundation, but then overlay with semiology from the Graduale Triplex. The two are not incompatible: you can keep your gestures tied to the counting of 2's and 3's, but then simply make the rate of counting quite variable, and the gestures rather customized and indescribable.

    Another interesting thing was way Solesmes conducting was covered concisely, in just one class period, at the end of which we were told, "This is all [of] chironomy. Is this clear?"

    Anyhow, I would contend that anyone interested in conducting chant ought at least to know the basics of how the traditional Solesmes method works.

    Do read, though, the chapter "Fundamental Concepts" in the Textbook of Chironomy for the author's opinion of where you ought be skill-wise to be considering wanting to conduct: whether or not you happen to measure up at this time, it is a refreshing perspective.
  • Where is Colloquium this year? Maybe my principal will let me go if he knows why.
    Thanked by 1canadash
  • The Colloquium will be in St. Paul, MN at the University of St.Thomas. June 19-24, 2017.
    Thanked by 1Casavant Organist
  • canadashcanadash
    Posts: 1,499
    You could try emailing Stephanie Martin at York University. She directs (or directed) Schola Magdalena. She may know of something close by.
  • In some ways, you really don't have to conduct chant at all: it is sometimes better not to conduct, and let the singers sing (even better, you can sing with them). If all else fails, you can simply give start and stop gestures and sing the chant with the schola.
  • I'll add this buttress to Clerget's observation just above -
    Following the vocal nuance and pace of the choirmaster's or cantor's or precentor's voice can be more effective than all the 'direction' in the world. If one can't sing well chant that is well understood, one really cannot direct it.
  • CCoozeCCooze
    Posts: 1,259
    I agree with Clerget. What it boils down to, and about the only thing I feel the need to somewhat direct anymore, are expressively extended tones (episemas, mostly, because bi- and tri-strophas should be obvious).
    Thanked by 1canadash
  • canadashcanadash
    Posts: 1,499
    It is true. I think my sons are very good at singing chant and they just take their time learning the ebbs and flows of the music. If you know it well, you will teach it well.