A Scholar on Liturgical Latin
  • dad29
    Posts: 2,217
    From Fr. Hunwicke:

    One of the greatest scholars of the twentieth century was a Dutch Classicist called Christine Mohrmann. In a long series of articles and books in all the main European languages, she demonstrated that Liturgical Latin (and, indeed, Liturgical Greek) were never intended to be be vernaculars; that, indeed, they were deliberately designed to be formal, archaic, and hieratic. I will let her speak to you in her own words:

    "Liturgical Latin, as constituted towards the end of Christian Antiquity and preserved unchanged - in its main lines at least - is a deliberately sacral stylisation of Early Christian Latin as it gradually developed in the Christian communities of the West. The Latin Christians were comparatively late in creating a liturgical language. When they did so, the Christian idiom had already reached full maturity and circumstances rendered it possible to draw, for purposes of style, on the ancient sacral heritage of [pagan] Rome ... As regards the plea which we hear so often for vernacular versions of the prayer texts, I think ... that we are justified in asking whether, at the present time, the the introduction of the vernacular would be suitable for the composition of sacral prayer style. As I have pointed out, the early Christian West waited a long time before adopting the use of Latin. It waited until the Christian language possessed the resources necessary to create an official ecclesiastical prayer language. ... the modern, so-called Western languages ... are less suitable for sacred stylisation. And yet we must realise that sacral stylisation forms an essential element of every official prayer language and that this sacral, hieratic character cannot, and should never, be relinquished. From the point of view of the general development of the Western languages - to say nothing of the problems raised by other languages - the present time is certainly not propitious for the abandonment of Latin".

    (end quotations)

    It's often mentioned that 'sacred time, sacred space, sacred language, and sacred music' are necessary elements in exercise of religious rites.

    What's not mentioned enough is the ....ahhh.... somewhat fraudulent and easily dis-proved theories on which Bugnini et.al. rested their "case" for the Revolution of 1965-69. Now that Fr. Bouyer's memoirs are available, it's clear that somebody should have been banished to Baghdad, or Tehran.

    Oh, wait!!
  • chonakchonak
    Posts: 9,160
    A lecture series by Mohrmann has been published as a small book, available at
    http://churchlatin.com/Books.aspx?BookID=3